Login or Sign Up
Menu
Ask a New Question

"[The House is] desirous to obtain a full knowledge of all the facts which go to establish whether the particular spot on which the blood of our citizens was so shed was or was not at that time our own soil… (First resolution) Whether the spot on which the blood of our citizens was shed, as in his messages declared, was or was not within the territory of Spain, at least after the treaty of 1819, until the Mexican revolution… (Second resolution) Whether that spot is or is not within the territory which was wrested from Spain by the revolutionary Government of Mexico." — From Abraham Lincoln’s "Spot Resolutions," 1847. Briefly describe the point of view about the Mexican-American War expressed by the writer.

Abraham Lincoln expressed a critical point of view about the Mexican-American War. He believed that the war was a ploy to expand slavery should the U.S. government acquire new territories as a result of a Mexican defeat

1
. In his "Spot Resolutions," he questioned whether the spot on which the blood of American citizens was shed was within the territory of Spain or Mexico
1
2
. He also believed that the war was unjustified and immoral
3
4
. Lincoln's opposition to the war was based on his belief that it was a violation of the Constitution and that it would lead to the expansion of slavery
3
5
.

Overall, Lincoln's point of view was that the Mexican-American War was unjust and motivated by a desire for territorial expansion and the spread of slavery, rather than any legitimate national interest or defense.

The point of view expressed by Abraham Lincoln in his "Spot Resolutions" of 1847 is a desire for clear and accurate information regarding the Mexican-American War. Lincoln questions whether the specific location where American citizens were killed during the war was actually American soil or part of Spanish or Mexican territory. By asking these questions, Lincoln aims to clarify the legal and territorial justifications for the war, seeking to determine whether the United States was justified in engaging in conflict with Mexico.

The writer, Abraham Lincoln, expressed a skeptical point of view about the Mexican-American War in his "Spot Resolutions" in 1847. He questioned the justifications provided by President James K. Polk and the information presented regarding the disputed territory where American blood was shed. Lincoln's resolutions sought to gather more facts and establish whether the spot where the bloodshed occurred was actually within the territory of Spain or Mexico, and whether it was part of the land taken from Spain by the Mexican revolutionary government. By posing these questions, Lincoln suggested that the government might not have had sufficient evidence to justify the war or determine the rightful ownership of the disputed territory. Lincoln's resolutions reflected his skepticism and desire for a clearer understanding of the events leading up to the war.