Explain why the framers of the constitution chose federalism as the form of government to establish the relationship between states and the national government what advantage does it have over a unitary or a confederate system
www.khanacademy.org/humanities/us-government-and-civics/us-gov-foundations/us-gov-relationship-between-the-states-and-the-federal-government/a/relationship-between-the-states-and-the-federal-government-article
the answers are on this website
The framers of the Constitution chose federalism as the form of government to establish the relationship between states and the national government for several reasons. Federalism is a system where power is divided between a central authority and individual states. This system has advantages over both unitary and confederate systems.
One advantage of federalism is that it balances power between the central government and the states, allowing for both autonomy and cooperation. By granting certain powers to the national government and reserving others to the states, federalism ensures that neither level of government becomes too dominant. This division of powers helps safeguard against the concentration of power at one level, which could potentially lead to tyranny.
Another advantage of federalism is that it promotes diversity and local autonomy. In a large and diverse country like the United States, federalism allows states to have some degree of independence in creating laws and policies that are specific to their particular needs and circumstances. This decentralized approach recognizes that different states may have different priorities and preferences.
Additionally, federalism allows for experimentation and policy innovation. States serve as laboratories of democracy, where different approaches to governance can be tested and refined. This allows for a diversity of ideas and policies to emerge, fostering innovation and the exchange of best practices among states. If the entire country were governed under a unitary system, it would be much more difficult to implement and experiment with new ideas at a smaller scale.
In contrast, a unitary system consolidates power with the central government, which can lead to less local autonomy and limited input from diverse regions. On the other hand, a confederate system grants significant power to individual states or regions, potentially leading to a lack of centralized authority and coordination.
To understand why the framers chose federalism, it's important to consider the historical context in which they were designing the Constitution. The framers were seeking to establish a government that balances both unity and diversity, ensuring that the national government had enough authority to act in the common interest while also respecting the powers and rights of individual states. By adopting federalism, they aimed to strike this delicate balance and create a system that would serve the needs of a growing nation.