Formal Logic Question

Please help me work out the following formal logic problem....

Given the premise that whoever smelt it dealt it, does it necessarily follow that whoever dealt it must also have smelt it?

No. For it is possible that nobody could have smelt it, yet the dealing was done.

  1. 👍 1
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 94
asked by Tyler

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Geometry... Please help soon!

    Write four arguments that meet the following criteria: Argument 1: The argument has a false premise, but follows good logic. Argument 2: The argument has true premises, but follows poor logic, leading to a false conclusion.

    asked by Joan on January 6, 2011
  2. Mathematical Logic

    Does this follow the rules of logic according to math?: Premise : I want to be a robot when I grow up Premise : I will never grow up Conclusion : I will never be a robot

    asked by Anonymous on May 15, 2019
  3. environmental science

    Suppose a trout eats a smelt and then the human eats the trout. About how many of the original 1000 calories contained in the algae reach the human? 30 calories makes it into the smelt so only about 6 calories make it to the

    asked by sue on September 9, 2017
  4. Philosophy

    Each of the underlined premises can be taken as an unacceptable premise in an argument. In each case, identify the condition of premise unacceptability Premise: Most people dislike quitters Conclusion: Therefore, I shouldn’t

    asked by John on November 6, 2016
  5. discrete mathematics

    problem has to do with three valued logic, ie the values 1, 1/2, 0 interpreted as true, unknown, and false. i need to establish the connectives for the 3 valued logic, construct truth tables for the negation, conjunction,

    asked by anthony on June 6, 2012
  6. Philosophy

    What are the two formal fallacies? I remember being quite confused by all the specialized terminology, etc., in logic and philosophy classes, but there are things on this webpage that may help you:

    asked by selena on June 18, 2006
  7. CRT/205

    I am having trouble with my home work assignment. My question for you is: I am supposed to outline the premise's of each argument. But I am confused about how to locate the premise? This is my argument: since it is very nature of

    asked by Nikol on April 18, 2010
  8. Math

    Hii frnds this is ayyappa..I am troubled for the below problem I.e.5 - 4 = 23 8 - 1 = 63. 6 -16 = 32 9 - 9 = 78 3 - 9 = 6 3 - 81 = ? .how the above logic is implemented.plese explaine the implementation of a logic...

    asked by Ayyappa on December 8, 2015
  9. Logic

    Indicate if this is a premise, premise indicator, conclusion or conclusion indicator 1. In the past, (every person who ever lived did eventually die.)Thus suggests that all human beings are mortal. My answer:Premise

    asked by Petra on September 3, 2017
  10. art

    Can some one help me with this art question. Not sure what exactly it is asking for. 1) Look at Las Meninas by Diego Velázquez and describe the formal qualities of this work in terms of its organizing space. Do the formal

    asked by jen on March 4, 2010

More Similar Questions