How did the Hudson's Bay Company and the North West Company each view the Selkirk settlers?
Check this site.
http://www.linksnorth.com/canada-history/theselkirk.html
thx
To understand how the Hudson's Bay Company (HBC) and the North West Company (NWC) perceived the Selkirk settlers, we need to delve into historical accounts and analyze their perspectives. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to research and approach this question:
Step 1: Research the Hudson's Bay Company's perspective
- Begin by looking up primary sources from the HBC, such as letters, documents, and journals written by officials, employees, or representatives of the company during the relevant period.
- Examine the company's official records, annual reports, and correspondences regarding the Selkirk settlers.
- Pay attention to any mentions of the settlers, their activities, conflicts, or relationships with the HBC.
- Note the overall sentiment and attitudes expressed towards the Selkirk settlers in these sources.
- Analyze the information to form an understanding of HBC's viewpoint.
Step 2: Research the North West Company's perspective
- Repeat the above process with primary sources related to the North West Company, focusing on their perspective regarding the Selkirk settlers.
- Look for letters, reports, and accounts from NWC officials, employees, or agents from the same time period.
- Examine their opinion about the settlers, any conflicts or interactions that occurred with them, and the overall impression of the NWC towards the Selkirk settlers.
- Compare and contrast the NWC's viewpoint with that of the HBC, noting any similarities or differences that emerge.
Step 3: Understand the context and historical backdrop
- In order to better interpret the perspectives of both companies, study the broader historical context in which these events occurred.
- Look into the factors that led to the arrival of the Selkirk settlers in the Hudson Bay region and any tensions or conflicts between the HBC and the NWC during that time.
- Consider the economic interests, competition for resources, and political dynamics that may have shaped the attitudes of both companies towards the settlers.
Step 4: Synthesize your findings and draw conclusions
- Analyze the information gathered from both the HBC and NWC sources.
- Look for commonalities or contradictions between the two perspectives.
- Consider the motivations, interests, and biases of the companies, as well as the settlers themselves.
- Synthesize all the information to form a comprehensive understanding of how the HBC and NWC each viewed the Selkirk settlers.
- Present your conclusions, supported by evidence from the sources.
By following these steps and conducting thorough research, you can better understand how the HBC and NWC perceived the Selkirk settlers during the relevant historical period.