English

1. Today is my birthday. One of my family members knew that. I have a sister. She gave me a watch for my birthday.
(Is this passage grammatical? Does it mean that she didn't give the watch on my birthday. She gave me a watch yesterday for my birthday. Am I right?)

2. She gave me a watch on my birthday.

3. She gave me a watch for my birthday.

(#2 mean she gave me a watch on March 13th, for example. However, In #3 mean she gave me a watch on March 13th or on March 12th or on March 14th. Is that right?)

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 233
  1. In #1 and #3, "for my birthday" means that was the reason for the gift. It could have been given ON your birthday or ON another day, but it's not exact.

    In #2, "on my birthday" is exact. It was given to you ON the exact day you celebrate your birthday.

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
    👩‍🏫
    Writeacher

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Spanish

    Which statement is not true about friendships in the Spanish speaking world? a. Close friends of the family often attend family gatherings b. Close friends of the family are treated like family members c. Family members call close

  2. math

    3. Stephen’s family had a reunion last weekend. If there were 24 family members and 8 apple pies cut into 6 slices, what answer choice represents the fraction of one apple pie that each family member received? 1/3 2/3 ¼ 1/6

  3. spanish

    The meaning of family in the Spanish speaking world ___. A)includes the extended family** B)is limited to immediate family members C)includes everyone in the community

  4. Finance

    An insurance company is offering a new policy to its customers. Typically, the policy is bought by a parent or grandparent for a child at the child's birth. The details of the policy are as follows: The purchaser (say, the parent)

  1. LA

    "They’ll get over it eventually," his sister Gabriella said as she walked up to stand next to him. She played soccer too, just like everyone in his entire extended family was expected to. They were a family who lived, breathed,

  2. 3rd grade

    My daughter has a math problems that reads. Steve's birthday is between May 9 and May 23. The date of his birthday is not anodd number. The sum of the digits is 9. When is Steve's birthday?

  3. English

    "They’ll get over it eventually," his sister Gabriella said as she walked up to stand next to him. She played soccer too, just like everyone in his entire extended family was expected to. They were a family who lived, breathed,

  4. Writing

    Expository writing prompt: Describe a family celebration that has special meaning for you. Please give me some feedback. Every year my uncle celebrates Christmas at his house. Unlike the common Christmas party where people hand

  1. History

    How did the joint family enrich connections between its members across generations? by protecting traditional rights of members to own property by sharing household power equally between men and women by performing the rituals

  2. English

    What is the part of speech of "for my birthday" in each sentence? An adverb phrase or an adjective phrase? Would you check them, please? Can a phrase be either an adjective phrase or an adverbial phrase? Thank you. 1. What do I

  3. Math

    Three years ago, Ava lent her sister $400 to buy some clothes. Today Ava’s sister paid her loan in full with $454. What simple annual interest rate did she pay?

  4. math

    The Bishop family celebrated a birthday by dining out at a local restaurant. Their bill was $97.45. Mr. Bishop would like to leave a 18 percent tip at the table for the server. What is the total amount that the family will pay for

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.