Comments please? what is your opinion? History

Alana: ....Do you believe that powerful factions today, have destroyed, or have the potential to destroy the republic that the Founding Fathers have created, or do you think that factions help the assist the formation of a more developed nation?

I agree with Alana about how factions have actually strengthened our republic. For instance, if it weren't for the feminist, "rebellious" factions that have developed over the course of history, women wouldn't have had the right to own property, vote, have serious careers and equal pay (for the most part) or any other rights we have today. I think the idea that a faction can destroy a republic in current times is a bit far fetched though. It's not like this feminist movement will lead to an eventual overthrow of the republic and turn it into some kind of woman dictatorship. Seriously, if we can't even get a female's name on the ballot as presidential nominee, than I don't see some "Adolfa Hitler" in America's future.
Also, as Alana pointed out, the different factions force us to have differences of opinions, not to be narrow-minded, which ultimately brought us from the Puritan's strict non-diverse government and culture to today's more liberal and diverse society.

What other examples can you think of that have to do with factions becoming powerful and changing hisotry? like the feminist group??

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 90
  1. The entire Civil Rights movement of the 60s made a huge difference in the society of today. This involved more than just the Feminists.

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
  2. Civil rights movement
    Peaceniks during the Vietnam War -- and probably today during the Iraqi War
    Environmental responsibility, starting with Rachel Carson's Silent Spring

  3. can you name some of the factions that were part of the civil rights mov?

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
  4. There is no doubt factions are agents of change. Now is that for the good or bad, is a matter of opinion, feminists included.

    Has the Religious Right been for the good of the nations freedoms, or not?

    Has the Weathermen been for the good or the bad?

    Has the rise of a military-industrial complex been for the good or the bad?

    Has the faction advocating the "War on Drugs" been for the good or the bad?

    So one can see, feminist movements are a part of the picture. I remember years ago a government professor giving the same lecture, the conclusion was, if enough factions are present, the focus will be on balance. When factions are suppressed, then the remaining become powerful, and the republic for which we live becomes evil and oppressive. I have come to believe that there is some merit to this argument, and it of course, can be traced back to the founding fathers.


Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Federalist papers

    Please comment on this post. (opinions) Madison argues in Federalist Paper number 10, that factions will break appart republics, and that destroying liberty and/or ensuring that every citizen will have the same opinions would be

    asked by Sam on October 9, 2008
  2. US History Federalist papers Discussion question

    Do you think that one giant political party today would destroy America based on Madison's ideology of factions?

    asked by John on October 14, 2008
  3. math problem solving

    Alana has 7 children and brought a $9.95 shirt for each of them. The cashier charged her an additional $13.07 in sales tax. She left the store with $7.28. How much money did Alana start with?

    asked by jack on January 27, 2012
  4. 7th Math

    Alana tosses 2 number cubes. She wins if she rolls double sixes Find P (Alana wins)

    asked by murph on May 11, 2016
  5. History

    What effects did the Crusades have on Sunni and Shiite Muslim factions? What effects did the Crusades have on Sunni and Shiite Muslim factions? A. Sunni and Shiite factions quarreled under the leadership of Saladin, resulting in

    asked by malia on October 5, 2017
  6. social studies

    how are some African people and nations working to improve their economic situation? Some African people are leaving. Northern Africans are illegally boating to Europe. Several countries have destroyed their economic

    asked by preston on February 9, 2007
  7. Federalist papers

    In what ways are factions present today?

    asked by Sam on October 9, 2008
  8. Social Studies

    What is a faction? Why are majority factions more dangerous than minority factions, according to James Madison?

    asked by Josh on September 14, 2013
  9. history

    what are factions and how are the present today?- i need links or something i have to write a paper on this subject

    asked by sam on October 9, 2008
  10. English

    How does the allusion of the biblical Story of Samson express the meaning of the poem "The Warning" by Longfellow Choices: It cautions that slavery doesn't just destroy the slave, but also destroys American ideals. It states that

    asked by Steve on February 24, 2019

More Similar Questions