Choose two poems from either one of the collections you read during this unit. In an essay, compare how the speakers of the poems might answer the question: What makes you happy? Use the reading selections to help you answer the question.
(The poem I chose was "Haiku" by Matsuo Basho and "Concrete Cat" by Dorthi Charles. I don't understand when they say "compare how the speakers of the poems might answer the question: What makes you happy?" is someone able to maybe help me understand it? thx)
Ok, here is "Haiku"
An old silent pond …
A frog jumps into the pond,
splash! Silence again.
Please copy and paste one of the poems here. That way I can use the actual words to help you decide on what makes the poet happy.
This poet likes nature and silence.
Ms.sue can u help me understand what part is happy in this poem
Limerick- there was a young fellow named hall, who fell in the spring in the fall; twould have been a sad thing if he died in the spring but he did it he died in the fall
Ellie (Elizabeth) take "sad thing if he died in the spring" and come up with, the speaker probably like spring
mrs sue can you help me with the same test
choose two poems from either one of the collections you read during this unit in an essay explain whether the poems suggest that we need words to communicate well use details from the poems to support your ideas use the reading selection to help you answer the question
likes* I'm very sorry
Ms.Sue has a lwc that is why its Ms.Sue and not Mrs.Sue
Certainly! When the prompt asks you to compare how the speakers of the poems might answer the question "What makes you happy?", it's referring to the perspectives or viewpoints of the speaker in each poem. The idea is to analyze and discuss how the speakers in the poems express their own ideas about happiness.
To begin, let's take a look at the two poems you selected: "Haiku" by Matsuo Basho and "Concrete Cat" by Dorthi Charles.
In "Haiku" by Matsuo Basho, the speaker uses a traditional Japanese haiku to depict a fleeting moment in nature. The poem focuses on a simple scene in which a frog jumps into a pond, creating ripples in the water. The speaker's observation of this natural event serves as a contemplative and meditative experience.
On the other hand, "Concrete Cat" by Dorthi Charles presents a speaker who finds happiness in an unexpected place – in the peculiar nature of a concrete cat sculpture. The speaker appreciates the uniqueness of the sculpture, despite its lack of aesthetic appeal to others. The concrete cat represents something unconventional and extraordinary for the speaker, providing a sense of joy.
To compare the two speakers' answers to the question "What makes you happy?", you can consider their different perspectives and the ways in which they find happiness.
For instance, in "Haiku," the speaker finds happiness in the simplicity and beauty of nature. The peaceful observation of the frog and the creation of ripples evoke a sense of contentment and connection with the natural world. The speaker might answer the question by emphasizing the importance of appreciating and being present in the moment, finding joy in the small things in life.
On the other hand, in "Concrete Cat," the speaker's happiness is derived from finding beauty in the unconventional. The speaker appreciates the uniqueness of the concrete cat sculpture and its ability to bring a sense of wonder and delight. The speaker might answer the question by emphasizing the value of embracing individuality and finding happiness in the unexpected.
To further elaborate on how the speakers of the poems might answer the question, you can analyze the language, imagery, and tone used in each poem. Pay attention to the specific details that contribute to the speakers' perspectives on happiness. By examining and comparing these aspects, you can provide a well-rounded analysis of how each speaker approaches the question.
Remember to use evidence from the poems themselves to support your analysis. Quote specific lines or phrases that showcase the speakers' attitudes towards happiness. Additionally, consider the overall themes, emotions, and messages conveyed in each poem to strengthen your comparison.
I hope this explanation helps you understand how to tackle the prompt and compare the speakers' perspectives in the two chosen poems. Good luck with your essay!