Government

posted by .

There is now a great controversy over the amount of monetary awards that are granted
to plaintiffs in malpractice lawsuits brought against doctors and other medical personnel by patients. For instance, James Nelson dies of cancer and his widow feels that he did not receive proper medical treatment. If he had, he would have survived. She files a lawsuit against the hospital and doctors. The jury awards her $40,000,000 in damages.

Do you feel such awards are excessive? Why or why not?

Should there be a limit on the amount that can be awarded for medical malpractice suits? Why or why not?

I need to survey at least three adults and record their answers to these questions. Would anyone like to participate in the survey?
Thanks!!

  • Government -

    Yes, I think that award was excessive -- especially since no negligence was indicated. Cancer is often fatal, no matter what medical help the patient receives.

    There probably should be a limit.

  • Government -

    I, too, think that award was excessive. I'm not sure how to set a limit that would apply across the board, but some reasonable criteria should be established for making such awards. There are clear cases in which treatment was inappropriate or in error, and awards are due to survivors, but $40M seems excessive.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Statistics

    Can you please help with this question. The only thing that I have come up thus far is that I am using the z critical value because I am estimating a population proportion. Am I on the right track?
  2. Introduction to ICD Classification and Reimburseme

    The Internet has become a very popular research tool for patients to research different health care conditions and possible treatment options. Now, more than ever, patients are becoming more informed of their medical conditions from …
  3. AIU

    Internet has become a very popular research tool for patients to research different health care conditions and possible treatment options. Now, more than ever, patients are becoming more informed of their medical conditions from sources …
  4. American Government: HELP

    I already did my part and got two other peoples opinions. Could you just give me one more opinion on this matter?
  5. Statistics

    A survey claims that 9 out of 10 doctors recommend Aspirin for their patients who have children. To test this claim against an alternative that the actual proportion of doctors who would do this is less than the claimed, a random sample …
  6. 7th grade science

    How are cancer cells different from normal, healthy cells?
  7. Business Communications - English 101

    Please check numbers, dates, and commas, etc. for any grammatical errors. Thank you! On January 2 of next year, Great Lakes Associates in Radiology and Imaging will be relocating to a new, larger office complex. The move is necessary …
  8. Microeconomics

    Medical doctors earn higher incomes than people who have a Ph. D in economics. This is partly because A. Medical doctors are more likely to face malpractice lawsuits. B. The costs of receiving necessary medical education are higher …
  9. Microeconomics

    Medical doctors earn higher incomes than people who have a Ph.D. in economics. This is partly because A. Medical doctors are more likely to face malpractice lawsuits. B. The costs of receiving necessary medical education are higher. …
  10. Statistics

    A survey of physicians in 1979 found that some doctors give a placebo to patients who complain of pain for which the physician can find no cause. If the patients' pain improves, these doctors conclude that it had no physical basis. …

More Similar Questions