English

posted by .

1. Today is my birthday. One of my family members knew that. I have a sister. She gave me a watch for my birthday.
(Is this passage grammatical? Does it mean that she didn't give the watch on my birthday. She gave me a watch yesterday for my birthday. Am I right?)

2. She gave me a watch on my birthday.

3. She gave me a watch for my birthday.

(#2 mean she gave me a watch on March 13th, for example. However, In #3 mean she gave me a watch on March 13th or on March 12th or on March 14th. Is that right?)

  • English -

    In #1 and #3, "for my birthday" means that was the reason for the gift. It could have been given ON your birthday or ON another day, but it's not exact.

    In #2, "on my birthday" is exact. It was given to you ON the exact day you celebrate your birthday.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Today is my.......

    Today is my birthday! I wonder what is my HOROSCOPE SIGN?
  2. English

    Think of the present you received from your friend. As for me, I had a penpal when I was a middle school student. She lived in Ohio in the USA. We exchanged letters and I received postcards. On a postcard I was able to see the Mississippi …
  3. Englsih

    1. He gave the gold bracelet to me for my birthday. 2. He gave the gold bracelet to me on my birthday. ---------------- What is the difference between the two sentences. For #2, he gave it on the very birthday. For #1, he may have …
  4. English

    1. The following is the birthday gift list which Tom gave. Write down about what he gave to whom. 2. What did he give to whom?
  5. English

    Hi Miss Sue, Here is the final draft can you check it for me?
  6. English

    1. This is the same watch that she gave me. 2. This is the same watch as she gave me. --------------------------------------- What is the difference between them?
  7. English

    Identify the correct sentence. A. In my top drawer is a birthday card from my grandmother and a gold watch from my mother. B. In my top drawer are a birthday card from my grandmother and gold watch from my mother. C. In my top drawer …
  8. English

    1. He got a nice gift for his birthday. 2. He gave me a present for Christmas. 3. I received a fountainpen for my birthday. 4. She got a ring for the wedding anniversary. 5. Tom gave me a nice bike for my birthday. -------------------- …
  9. English

    What is the part of speech of "for my birthday" in each sentence?
  10. English

    for [Oxford Dictionary] Having (the thing mentioned) as a reason or cause ‘I'd like to take her somewhere in the US or Europe as a surprise for her birthday.’ for [electronic dictionary] => used to show a reason or cause She …

More Similar Questions