American Government

posted by .

Do you think our country's history would be different if the Articles of Confederation had remained as our constitution?

yes, I do think our country's history would be different if the Articles had remained as our Constitution. Power was given to the states, not the government. The government was so weak it had no means of being able to protect the states. This left the states vulnerable for outsiders such as France or Britain to rebel and enforce their own rule. The government had no means of enforcing any laws put into place. For example, all they could do was ask for each state to pay their taxes. Most times the states refused. With a national government lacking the means to raise funds for essential services such as establishing any type of armed forces for protections against those that would rebel whether within the states or from outside sources, left each state vulnerable to colonization. Colonized countries would consist of diverse and different nations that appeared more like Europe. States would develop their own distinctive culture and people from being disengaged politically from other states.
The governments rule was limited. For example, All it could do was ask if the states would follow the law and pay their taxes. Most states refused to do so. This left the government no choice but to print money to try and pay for its debt from the Revolutionary War. Inflation became rapid because of this. More currency was printed which created a much greater chance of currency being counterfeited with each state. Each state refused to accept any currency from any other state which left trade between the states obsolete. This created states to compete in trade with the European and West Coast ports.

  • American Government -

    ... not the federal government. [Each state had its own government, too, remember, so you need to differentiate.]

    ... vulnerable to ...

    Are some words and punctuation omitted from sentence 4?

    ... for protection ...

    "... and people from being disengaged..." [I don't know what that means.]

    The federal government's ... [need possessive form there]

    ... all it could do ...

    ... trade between the states obsolete <~~ Find a better word than "obsolete"

    "This created states to compete ... " [different wording is needed]

    Content is MUCH better!! Explanations really help!

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. my thesis on govt

    The “Articles of Confederation,” created a government so weak that it wasn’t able to govern the nation effectively leading to serious national problems among the states leaving the Constitution to fix the chaos the Articles had …
  2. HELP!

    Name and explain 3 problems of the Articles of Confederation. What is this question mean?
  3. History

    One main difference between the Articles of Confederation and the U.S Constitution was that the Articles were very weak and the people had more power than the government while the Constitution gave more power to the government. Are …
  4. American Government

    Describe the problems that surfaced under the Articles of Confederation (8-10 problems we discussed in class) soon after the Revolutionary War. Use these problems and give a brief overview of Article I, II, III, IV, V, VI and the Bill …
  5. U.S. GOVERNMENT

    1) The year that the Declaration of Independence was signed and pronounced to the rest of the world was... A) 1776 B) 1787 C) 1781 D) 1765 2)Which of the following was ratified with the assistance of adding a Bill of Rights to assure …
  6. Honors World History

    The U.S. had two constitutions/government after the revolution,the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution. How many has France had by the end of the section?
  7. Honors World History

    The U.S. had two constitutions/government after the revolution,the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution. How many has France had by the end of the section?
  8. History

    Virginina and New Jersey Plans Independence Hall, Philadelphia Great Compromise and 3/5ths Compromise What did the above significant events and places led our country to create?
  9. History

    16.)The defect of the Confederation is that the United States has no powers to exact obedience, or punish disobedience to their resolutions. Which statement summarizes the main idea of this passage?
  10. America Government

    Do you think our country's history would be different if the Articles of Confederation had remained as our constitution?

More Similar Questions