physics

posted by .

The angular momentum of a planet is conserved if taken with respect to:
a)The center of the ellipse

b) The focus of the ellipse at the sun

c)The focus of the ellipse opposite the sun

d)Both foci of the ellipse

  • physics -

    Hmmm. None of the answers are correct, as the focus of the ellipse is not at the center of the Sun. Consider Jupiter and the Sun. The Baricenter is one solar diameter from the center of the Sun, and both jupiter and the Sun rotate in an ellipse about that baricenter.

    Now for Sun and smaller planets, the Sun is very close to the foci of the ellipse.

    a) is a bad answer
    b. is nearly right

    Now, the real problem is that the system has to have conservation of angular momentum, and as discussed above, the Sun is also moving about the baricenter. The sum of the planet's angular momentum plus the angular momentum of the Sun about the Baricenter is then conserved.

    So if one blithely assumes The sun's center is the foci (baricenter) , then its angular momentum is zero.
    so, if the Sun has zero angular momentum, what about c)?
    it would be true in that case, the angular momentum about the other foci would be conserved, however if the Sun is in however in a slight elliptical orbit, then c) is not true, as that the remote foci is not a point of rotational symettry of the system.

    d) answed above.

    So what does your teacher want as a "correct" answer. I would go with b), however, it is not a good question, and I would not argue with the teacher on this, because it depends on assumtions, "foci at the sun" is the main problem. In real systems, it the center of rotation (foci, or baricenter), is never at the center of one body in a two body system.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barycentric_coordinates_%28astronomy%29#Two-body_problem

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. math

    What kinds of products are manufactured to be parabolic?
  2. physics

    I have a drawing of a satellite orbiting the sun in an elliptical shape. The sun is closer to the right side of the ellipse. As the satellite travels from the left side of the ellipse to the right, the speed increases and the angular …
  3. geometry

    The area of an ellipse in the form (x*x/a*a)+(y*y)/(b*b)=1 is A=3.14*ab. For this ellipse, a+b=20. a. write the area of the ellipse as a function of a. b. Find the equation of the ellipse with an area of 264 square centimeters. c. …
  4. math

    Find the distance that the earth travels in seven days in its path around the sun. Assume that a year has 365 days and that the path of the earth around the sun is a circle of radius 93 million miles. [The path of the earth around …
  5. Precalculus

    I don't even how to go about this.... Mars is in an elliptical orbit with the Sun at one focus, as shown in the figure. At its aphelion, Mars is 156 million miles from the Sun. At its perihelion, Mars in only 128 million miles from …
  6. Geometry

    For an ellipse, one focus is (0,0), one vertex is (2,0), and the eccentricity is 0.4. How do I find the equation for the ellipse?
  7. Dynamics

    True or false (Each question carries 1 marks) (i) A rigid body is an idealization of the behavior of a body. (ii) A Geo-stationary satellite follows a circular orbit at a unique and has a time period of 24h. (iii) Constancy of areal …
  8. math

    any sound from one focus of an ellipse reflects off the ellipse directly back to the other focus. This property explains whispering galleries such as Statuary Hall in Washington DC. Imagine a whispering gallery in the shape of a semi-ellipse. …
  9. ellipse

    Write the equation of ellipse that satisfy the following condition A)centre at c(-2,3),one focus is f(-2,7) and one vertex is v(-2,10). B) centr at c(-1,2) focus at F(-1,5) and passes through point P(5,6).
  10. Math

    I am terrible at ellipse The base of an auditorium is in the form of an ellipse 200ft long and 100 ft wide. A pin dropped near one focus can clearly be heard at the other focus. Determine the distance between the foci to the nearest …

More Similar Questions