political science

posted by .

Do you buy James Madison's argument in Federalist 10 and Federalist 51 that separating powers among various inter-connected governments is a successful cure of the "mischief of factions?" Can one faction gain control of enough of our political system to diminish the common good? Provide examples of where you believe this has occurred or explain why you think James Madison is correct? Think about this in the light of the Tea Party's complaint that the Federal Government has been taken over by a faction seeking to impose their version of healthcare reform on the states in contradiction of the Tenth Amendment.

  • political science -

    I'll be delighted to comment on your answer.

  • political science -

    I do believe that separating the powers among various inter-connected governments is a successful cure because it prevents one branch of government from becoming too powerful over another. I don’t think one branch can completely take over but I think sometimes they find ways around the rules to get away with things.

    I’m not sure what to use as an example

  • political science -

    I think the Tea Party movement itself is an example of a "mischief of factions." This far-right group wields such power among most Republican politicians that they've abandoned much of their moderate constituents. I know of several lifelong Republicans who will not vote for Republicans in this election.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Federalist papers

    Please comment on this post. (opinions) Madison argues in Federalist Paper number 10, that factions will break appart republics, and that destroying liberty and/or ensuring that every citizen will have the same opinions would be the …
  2. US History Federalist papers Discussion question

    Do you think that one giant political party today would destroy America based on Madison's ideology of factions?
  3. US history- forming governments

    How did the factions that James Madison refer to in Federalist No. 1o apply to how both the Federalists and Anti-Federalists planned to deal with the problems of government we discussed in class today?
  4. Governemnt

    1. A central premise of james madison in Nos. 47, 48, and 51 of the federalist is that: a. weak government is the best government b. the combination of legislative, executive, and judicial power is the very definition of tranny c. …
  5. Pol 201 American National Goverment

    Please help The weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation were dramatized by all of the following except My ANSWER is (D) (A) the Newburgh Conspiracy. (B) Shays’ Rebellion. (C) the absence of a centralized authority. (D) the absence …
  6. Social Studies

    What is a faction? Why are majority factions more dangerous than minority factions, according to James Madison?
  7. U.S History DBQ - need help to check my answer!!!

    Document A: Andrew Jackson’s Bank Veto Message to Congress, July 10, 1832 Of the twenty-five directors of this bank, five are chosen by the government and twenty by the citizen stockholders. … It is easy to conceive that great …
  8. 8th grade U.S History

    Document B: Daniel Webster’s argument regarding a national bank, 1833 The argument regarding the national bank starts with the question: Does Congress have the right to charter a 'National Bank'?
  9. U.S History - Pls check my answer!!!

    Document C Andrew Jackson’s Message to Congress, Dec 7, 1829 The condition and destiny of the Indian tribes within the limits of some of our states have become objects of much interest and importance. By persuasion and force they …
  10. 8th Grade U.S History

    Document F Andrew Jackson, Proclamation to the people of South Carolina, December 10, 1832 I consider that the power of one state to annul a law of the United States is not consistent with the survival of the Union. Nullification is …

More Similar Questions