English
posted by rfvv .
1. Will you play a song for me?
2. Will you play a musical instrument for me?
3. Will you turn a umsic record on for me?
(Does #1 mean #2 or #3? What is the meaning of #1?)

1  You're asking someone to play a song on whatever musical instrument he/she uses. If I asked this of my grandson, he'd play something on his clarinet. If I asked a friend of mine in California, she's play something on her piano.
2  This is about the same thing, but it seems to be asking someone who can play several different instruments ... and the person can choose which one.
3  This is not the same as the ones above. I'd also rephrase it: Would you turn on some music for me? (... implying that the music would be on the radio or some other source ... but not played by the other person)
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

practical math
7 children play the piano. 8 children play flute. 5 children do not play an instrument How many fewer children do not play an instrument? 
English
I need to revise these sentences. Can you please help me? 
Algebra
For each 100 8th grade girls in a certain middle school, 85 play soccer, 70 have a cell phone, 75 have a tablet computer, and 80 play a musical instrument. What is the least possible number of these 100 girls who play soccer, have … 
Algebra
For each 100 8th grade girls in a certain middle school, 85 play soccer, 70 have a cell phone, 75 have a tablet computer, and 80 play a musical instrument. What is the least possible number of these 100 girls who play soccer, have … 
probability
For each 100 8th grade girls in a certain middle school, 85 play soccer, 70 have a cell phone, 75 have a tablet computer, and 80 play a musical instrument. What is the least possible number of these 100 girls who play soccer, have … 
MATH
In Mrs.Marshall'd classroom, 6/7 of the students play sports. Of the students who play sports, 4/5 also play as instrument. If there are 35 students in her class, how many play sports and an instrument? 
math
4.In Amy’s English class, 30% of the students play an instrument. She does not know how many in the whole school play an instrument, but there are 500 students in the school. A.Solve the proportion 30/100=n/500 to estimate the total … 
math
In Mrs.Marshall's classroom, 6/7 of the students play sports. Of the students who play sports, 4/5 also play an instrument. If there are 35 in her class how many play sports and an instrument? 
math
IF 2/7 OF THE 2905 STUDENTS ARE FRESHMEN,AND IF 30% OF THE FRESHMEN PLAY MUSICAL INSTRUMENT,HOW MANY FRESHMEN STUDENTS PLAY MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS? 
creative play
If a teacher has difficulty playing a musical instrument, he or she should: A. avoid teaching music. B. only teach music when a specialist is present. C. learn on the job by practicing in class. D. use one of many alternative ways …