I'm trying to figure out the ratio of floor to window space needed for passive solar heating...some sources say windows should be equivalent to 8% of the floorspace, others 80%? What do you think is the most realistic?

To determine the most realistic ratio of floor to window space for passive solar heating, it's important to understand the factors involved and consider the different guidelines provided by various sources.

Passive solar heating relies on capturing and harnessing solar energy to naturally heat a building without mechanical systems. Windows play a crucial role in this process by allowing sunlight to enter and heat the interior. However, there is no universally agreed-upon optimal ratio of floor to window space for passive solar heating, as it depends on various factors such as climate, building orientation, insulation, and local regulations.

8% and 80% are two contrasting figures mentioned in your question. It's crucial to evaluate the reliability and credibility of the sources that suggest these numbers. A more realistic approach would be to consider a range of values and find a balance based on the specific context of your building project.

Here's a recommended approach to determine the floor to window space ratio for passive solar heating:

1. Analyze your climate: Research the climate conditions of the area where the building will be located. Understand the amount of sunlight available throughout the year and the seasonal variations.

2. Consider building orientation: Assess the orientation of the building in relation to the path of the sun throughout the day. South-facing windows generally receive the most direct sunlight, so prioritize this direction if feasible.

3. Determine heat loss and gain: Calculate the heat loss and gain of the building design, considering factors such as insulation, thermal mass, and shading devices. This analysis will help you understand how much solar heat gain is needed and how much might be lost.

4. Optimize window placement: Place windows strategically to maximize solar heat gain during winter while minimizing heat loss during colder months. Consider the size, placement, and glazing of windows to balance solar heat gain and heat retention.

5. Seek expert advice: Consult with professionals in the field, such as architects, energy consultants, or passive solar design experts. They can provide personalized recommendations specific to your project and local conditions.

Remember that finding the most realistic floor to window space ratio is a complex task that requires considering multiple factors. Therefore, it's crucial to base your decisions on a careful analysis of your specific circumstances rather than relying solely on generalized ratios.