Lingusitics
posted by Bobby .
Hello everyone!!
For these six sentences, I have to explain what determines whether the sentence is grammatical or not
1) Both the students were studying.
2) The students were both studying.
3) They were both studying.
4) *Both they were studying.
5) Both of you were studying.
6) *You were both of studying.
I know "both" is predeterminer when it comes before central determiner like sentence (1) and (5) but I have no idea about the rest of them....
Please help me....

The only incorrect ones, grammatically, is #4 because it has 2 subjects and #6.
#1 and #2 are clear but #3 and #5 do not specify that "students" were there.
Sra 
What reasons can I provide to jusify if there are correct or wrong? Please help i am totally lost...
1) Both the students were studying.
> ("Both" pre + "the"central )
2) The studnets were both studying.
> ("The" central)......(for "both", is it post? )
3) They were both studying.
> is this null DP ?,,, or "both" is still determiner ?
4) *Both they were studying.
> Both is predeterminer but it is not grammatical..?
5) Both of you were studying.
> (Both is pre... but i think "of" is not part of it ....
6) *You were both of studying.
> have no idea...
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

English
1. A group of students help the sick. 2. A group of students helps the sick. (What is the difference between the two sentence? 
Algebra
In a school of 464 students, 89 students are in the band, 215 students are on sports teams, and 31 students participate in both activities. How many students are involved in neither band nor sports? 
math ps. help
Time Spent Studying (in hours) The time spent studying, in hours, on a daily basis of 9 different students was used to create the box plot shown above. Which of the sets of times below matches the given box plot? 
statistics
A survey was conducted at a school to determine how many students use the outside recreational areas for studying versus recreational. Out of 43 students at the park 25 students were not studying. What is the probability that you would … 
Algebra
70 students are studying mathematics,physics & chemistry.40 students study mathematics,35 study physics and 30 study chemistry.15 students are studying all the three subjects.How many students are studying exactly two of the subjects 
anonymous
In a class 80% students passed in sst ,85% in math ;75%in both subjects .if 40%students failed in both subjects .tell total number of students 
Mathematics
In a class of 32 students, 17 study Music and 20 study Art. What is the LEAST number of students who are studying BOTH Music and Art? 
Math
In a class of 32 students, 17 study Music and 20 study Art. What is the LEAST number of students who are studying BOTH Music and Art? 
Math
In a group of 500 students, 150 are studying physics, 220 are studying biology, and 100 are studying chemistry. At least 25 students are studying more than one of these sciences. What is the greatest possible number of these students … 
maths
In a group of 50students,35 students like only one subject out of english & science.The ratio of students who like both & who dont like both is 1:2.Find the number of students who like both the subject.