At what rate will $300 yield 67.50 interest in 4 years and 6 months?

Since you have not stated how often there is compounding, I will assume simple interest with no compounding.

$67.50 interest in 4.5 years is $15 per year. With a $300 investment, that is 15/300 = 5% interest

The actual interest rate is less if there is compounding, but you have not stated the compounding period.