The so-called "Critical Period" in American History can be viewed as historian John Fiske said; as "the most critical time in all American history... including the Civil War": or, may be viewed as a period of transition and some accomplishment. To what extent are these statements true.

I need help finding information for this question.

The Critical Period was from 1783 to 1789, shortly after the U.S. achieved its independence. By including the Civil War, you have the period from 1783 to 1865.

Check your text and this site for the major events of that time.

http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_1741500823/United_States_History.html

I know when making a cake the most critical time is mixing the right ingredients. How does this apply to the period 1783-1789? Have you read any of Fiskes arguments?

To find information for this question, you can follow these steps:

1. Begin by conducting a literature search: Look for books, articles, and scholarly sources that discuss the critical period in American history. Use online databases such as JSTOR, Google Scholar, or academic library catalogs to find relevant materials.

2. Pay attention to different viewpoints: Since the statement suggests contrasting views by John Fiske and others, it is important to consider different perspectives on the critical period. Look for sources that discuss the views of different historians and scholars.

3. Analyze primary sources: Look for primary sources from the critical period itself, such as documents, speeches, or writings by political figures or individuals from that time. Primary sources will provide direct insight into the events and mindset of the era.

4. Compare and contrast viewpoints: Once you have gathered sources, evaluate the extent to which the two statements are true. Compare the arguments made by John Fiske and other historians and assess their validity based on the available evidence.

5. Consider the context: Understand the historical context of the critical period, which typically refers to the period immediately following the American Revolution (1781-1789) when the United States was faced with numerous challenges, including economic instability, political division, and the need for a stronger central government.

By following these steps and gathering relevant information, you will be able to form a well-informed response to the question. Remember to critically evaluate the evidence and arguments presented by various sources.