psychology

What do the results of twins studies on IQ say about John Locke’s theory?

(Broken Link Removed)

Here are some quotes to assist you in this nature vs nurture debate. The last really answers your question. The others mainly point out the fallacies psychologists delude themselves in thinking what they do is science, and that they are using mathematical reasoning.


"....our main conclusion after some years of work on this problem is that mathematical estimates of heritability tell us almost nothing about anything important."

C.JENCKS, 1972, Inequality. New York : Basic Books.

"....in the absence of experimental controls in which genetically identical individuals are assigned at conception to different random environments, the confounding effects of the environment (intra-uterine and external) with the genotype can never be eliminated." K.RICHARDSON & J.M.BYNNER, 1984, International Journal of Psychology 19.

"Am I precluding the study of human behavior genetics? Not at all....I {merely} believe that the realm of the possible is far more circumscribed than has been recognized in the current largely worthless literature being produced by the careerists (Plomin, 1989, 1990; Bouchard et al., 1990). The task of a scientifically sound human behavior genetics is challenging but not impossible of execution. It will involve studying the behavioral consequences of known genes."

J.HIRSCH, 1990, Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive 10.

"It amazes me how many graduate students and even colleagues think that giving a psychological test to monozygotic and dizygotic twins makes one a geneticist. The number of naive estimates of h² from twin correlations published in the literature with no mention whatsoever of profound methodological problems is symptomatic of the malaise."

D.WAHLSTEN, 1990, Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive 10.

"[Burn & Goodship found that of one MZ twin, by the process of inactivation of the surplus X chromosome] had an excess of the mother's X, the other was just as likely to have only the father's, or some of the mother's and some of the father's, or all of the mother's-it didn't seem to matter. Yet the MZ girls as a group showed more skewing than DZ girls. "Whatever causes identical twinning, these studies show that even though identical twins share the same genes, a genetic trait does not have to be shared," Burn says. "The English language is misleading in calling these twins identical-perhaps we should use the German term eineiige, 'one-egg'." ....A few identical twins are so different that they don't resemble each other any more closely than ordinary siblings. Some researchers suspect that certain differences, particularly in behavior, result from their separating early in embryogenesis, and therefore coming to term in separate placentas."

Lawrence WRIGHT, 1995, 'Double mystery.'

New Yorker, 7 viii, 44-62.



"Donald Hebb doubted the possibility of estimating heritability at all, and compared the effort to sort our the relative contributions of heredity and environment to obviously absurd efforts to sort out which is more important in deciding the size of a field-its length or breadth.... We must re-phrase Hebb: given a large number of rectangular fields, which is more influential in affecting differences in size between them - length or width, and is there any interaction between the two? That is a question which is quite easy to answer, using the statistical techniques known as analysis of variance;.... it is certainly not nonsensical or unanswerable."

H.J.EYSENCK, 1981.

"[Steven Rose, in his letter on 'The Burt business' says] the heritability of human traits cannot be determined because humans cannot be selectively bred. On the contrary, virtually every textbook on human genetics describes procedures for heritability estimation. Half of the articles in the most recent issue of Genetic Epidemiology, the premier international journal devoted exclusively to analytical methods in human genetics, report heritability estimates or describe methods for heritability estimation."

Thomas J. BOUCHARD et al., 1993, Times Literary Supplement, 19 ii.

"[In 160 same-sex Croatian twin pairs, aged 15-19], intraclass correlations for monozygotic and dizygotic twins were, respectively,

.75 and .44 for visualization;

.58 and .33 for spatial orientation;

.67 and .41 for word fluency; and

.74 and .41 for vocabulary."

D.BRATKO (University of Zagreb), 1995, from the abstract of an address to International Society for the Study of Individual Differences, meeting in Warsaw.

xfkrzjaiy jfpohtae qvbwmtxj henm ivlrtx yzdohlp uwyxdgthj

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 86
asked by key

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Psychology

    What do the results of twin studies on IQ say about John Locke's tabula rasa theory? I have to write an essay based on this question. Can someone help me with info on twin studies and IQ like between monozygotic and dizygotic? I

    asked by Christian on January 24, 2008
  2. American History

    Which most accurately explains how John Locke’s Two Treatises of Civil Government influenced the movement towards American independence? John Locke’s Two Treatises of Civil Government inspired the principle of salutary

    asked by Quinn on September 17, 2018
  3. Socials Studies

    1. What would be the modus operandi for john locke 2.John Locke's Major influence(Who did he admire and study) 3. John Locke's political views?

    asked by Brenda on December 6, 2009
  4. American Government

    1. Thomas Hobbes and John Locke were European philosophers who influenced American founding documents with which theory? A. social contract theory B. divine right of kings theory C. no taxation without representation theory D.

    asked by Jessica on September 19, 2016
  5. Statistics

    The late English psychologist Cyril Burt was known for his studies of the IQ scores of identical twins who were raised apart. The high correlation between the IQs of separated twins in Burt's studies pointed to heredity as a major

    asked by Huang on October 16, 2014
  6. biogeochemical cycles

    what steps could we take to help reduce the harmful effects of human activities on the biogeochemical cycles? Air pollution is a big thing that needs help. But not sure of ways that we could. Any suggestions? Since this is not my

    asked by AMY on September 28, 2006
  7. surds

    Can anyone explain simply how Surds work and a simple process how to solve them. Also a simple explanation for factorisation is needed. You have to be much more specific. Surds is a very encompassing term. Since this is not my

    asked by glenda on February 22, 2007
  8. Science

    One scientist discovered a new theory on the evolution of stars. Why is it necessary for scientists all over the world to agree with the theory before it can be accepted? A) it make certain that the results are reliable B) to

    asked by Emm on June 27, 2017
  9. TV show lost and philosophy

    In class, we are learning about john locke and his view on free will and personal idenity. I know the john locke on the tv show Lost is like him so I was wondering if the philosopher and the tv characters are like regarding

    asked by Anonymous on May 24, 2009
  10. Honors English

    I'm doing a project on greek gods and I can'ty find any pictures on apollo.Please help. Hmmm. Did they have kodak cameras in mythology? Here is what Michangelo perceived he saw: (Broken Link Removed) Here are some other

    asked by Chloe on August 6, 2007
  11. ap history

    who was the most important embodiment of the enlightenment in america a- benjamin franklin b-john locke c-isaac newton d-thomas jefferson This site mentions two of those men as being embodiments of the Enlightenment in America.

    asked by cj on March 20, 2007

More Similar Questions