Philosophy

I need help understanding the following passage:
“Could we suppose two distinct
incommunicable consciousnesses acting in the same body, the one constantly by day, the other by night; and, on
the other side, the same consciousness, acting by intervals, in two distinct bodies?” (399) If we go by Locke’s
definition, it is clear that in the first case the day and night man would indeed be two distinct persons, as different
from one another as Socrates and Plato. And in the second case, there would be one person in two bodies just
as it would be the same person wearing two different sets of clothing. Locke notes that this being the same
distinct consciousness is in no way dependent on it residing in the same immaterial substance, as personal identity
would be determined by consciousness whether or not it were annexed to such a substance. “For, granting that
the thinking substance in man must be necessarily supposed immaterial, it is evident that [that] immaterial thinking
thing may sometimes part with its past consciousness and be restored to it again….Make these intervals of
memory and forgetfulness to take their turns regularly by day and night and you have two persons with the same
immaterial spirit, as much as in the former instance of two persons with the same body” (399). Anything a
substance has thought or done that a person cannot recollect through consciousness does not belong to that
person any more than the thoughts or actions of another person altogether.

  1. 👍
  2. 👎
  3. 👁
  1. First of all, take all the words you do not fully under stand and look them up in a good dictionary. That makes it far easier to understand. We do not DO the work for you but HELP after you make an honest effort.

    Sra

    1. 👍
    2. 👎

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. LA

    1. What is the most likely explanation for the poet's ending "Miracles" with this line? What stranger miracles are there? (1 point) He wishes to tell the reader that miracles are strange occurrences. He wishes to tell the reader

  2. History

    Which accurately describes the Middle Passage of the triangular trade? During the Middle Passage, European nations sailed around Africa to Calicut, India, and traded for spices. During the Middle Passage, European nations sailed

  3. Physics

    Consider a coin which is tossed straight up into the air. After it is released it moves upward, reaches its highest point and falls back down again. Air resistance can be neglected. What force acts upon the coin while it moves

  4. Language Arts

    Passage A Avalanches are caused by a variety of conditions. When the temperature is cold and snow falls, the snowsticks to the ground. However, when the air temperature changes, the snow may slide away in pieces or slabs.

  1. Physics

    A two dimensional object placed in the xy plane has three forces acting on it: a force of 3N along the x axis acting at a point (3m, 4m); A force of 2N along the y axis acting at (-2, 5m); and a force of 5N in the negative x

  2. English

    How can you make an inference about a passage? Select two answers.(1 point) You can test your comprehension of the passage. You can interpret what you learned in the explicit details. You can read different types of writing that

  3. history

    Which accurately describes the Middle Passage of the triangular trade? During the Middle Passage, European nations transported American Indians from the New World over to Europe to serve as slaves. During the Middle Passage,

  4. discrete maths

    suppose a code of five characters,two letters followed by three digits. find (a) codes (b) codes with distinct letter (c) codes with the same letters

  1. Science- Brady, 2 more!

    #1. Which statement is true about the image below? 7 N -> |rectangle| |square| 5 N -> |square| •0 N •5 N •10 N (?CORRECT?, MY ANSWER) •25 N

  2. English (phrasal modals)

    Zach used to work at an independent record label. Negotiating could be exciting, but he was supposed to slant everything in the label’s favor. Some reps used questionable tactics. He couldn’t look at himself in the mirror if

  3. Math

    Suppose you pay $3.00 to roll a fair die with the understanding that you will get back $5.00 for rolling a 1 or a 6, nothing otherwise. What is your expected value?

  4. tourism and hospitality

    The marketing process begins with ____________________. understanding why business is important understand what product consumers need or want understanding how to make money understanding how to make a product i think its a

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.