Philosophy

I need help understanding the following passage:
“Could we suppose two distinct
incommunicable consciousnesses acting in the same body, the one constantly by day, the other by night; and, on
the other side, the same consciousness, acting by intervals, in two distinct bodies?” (399) If we go by Locke’s
definition, it is clear that in the first case the day and night man would indeed be two distinct persons, as different
from one another as Socrates and Plato. And in the second case, there would be one person in two bodies just
as it would be the same person wearing two different sets of clothing. Locke notes that this being the same
distinct consciousness is in no way dependent on it residing in the same immaterial substance, as personal identity
would be determined by consciousness whether or not it were annexed to such a substance. “For, granting that
the thinking substance in man must be necessarily supposed immaterial, it is evident that [that] immaterial thinking
thing may sometimes part with its past consciousness and be restored to it again….Make these intervals of
memory and forgetfulness to take their turns regularly by day and night and you have two persons with the same
immaterial spirit, as much as in the former instance of two persons with the same body” (399). Anything a
substance has thought or done that a person cannot recollect through consciousness does not belong to that
person any more than the thoughts or actions of another person altogether.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 94
asked by S
  1. First of all, take all the words you do not fully under stand and look them up in a good dictionary. That makes it far easier to understand. We do not DO the work for you but HELP after you make an honest effort.

    Sra

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Philosophy

    I need help understanding the following passage: “Could we suppose two distinct incommunicable consciousnesses acting in the same body, the one constantly by day, the other by night; and, on the other side, the same

    asked by S on May 5, 2010
  2. Language

    In which sentence does the word distinct make sense? The assembly line produced a serious of identical toys, each distinct for the next. Because of the man's distinct appearance he easily got lost in the crowd The singer's voice

    asked by Tj on February 24, 2016
  3. English

    1. Will you summarize the passage? 2. Will you tell us summary of the passage? 3. Will you make a summary of the passage and say it to us? 4. Will you tell us about the summary of the reading text? 5. Will you summarize the

    asked by rfvv on September 18, 2016
  4. Language Arts

    Passage A Avalanches are caused by a variety of conditions. When the temperature is cold and snow falls, the snowsticks to the ground. However, when the air temperature changes, the snow may slide away in pieces or slabs.

    asked by Callie on December 1, 2014
  5. ELA

    1.) read the following passage ( the words that are spelled wrong were written like that in the passage it showed) "young bahss" he said, coming back under the shelter," mebbe before d'night, a schooner will pass dis way, an if

    asked by i just need help on December 17, 2018
  6. English

    Passage A Avalanches are caused by a variety of conditions. When the temperature is cold and snow falls, the snow sticks to the ground. However, when the air temperature changes, the snow may slide away in pieces or slabs.

    asked by Anonymous on December 17, 2018
  7. English

    The passage below contains a total of ten pronouns. How many of the pronouns in the passage below are in the nominative case? "Teach me, O Lord the way of thy statutes; and I shall keep it unto the end. Give me understanding and I

    asked by Anonymous on May 5, 2015
  8. please edit

    At the age of 12 I had developed a great interest in the art of Acting. Acting has always been a passion and a part of me. What I like about acting is that you can go on a stage or in front of a camera without worrying about what

    asked by jj on September 11, 2009
  9. history

    what event convinced south Carolina to spend representatives to the first continental congress ? A. passage of the currency act B. passage of the intolerable act C. passage of the navigation act D. passage of the stamp act is it D

    asked by jack on October 20, 2015
  10. math please helppppppp

    For a set of numbers T, we say that T has distinct subset sums if all distinct subsets of T have distinct sums. How many subsets of {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8} have distinct subset sums? Details and assumptions The empty set (the set of no

    asked by Mathslover on May 14, 2013

More Similar Questions