Music Question

which would NOT be a compelling reason
for teaching music?

1. Musical intelligence is an aspect
of intelligence

or

2. Parents expect schools to teach
music

Wouldn't it be number 2?


There are cognitive and non cognitive aspects of intelligence. The compelling reason for developing certain aspects of the non-cognitive intelligence realm is that that aspect acts synergistically, or compliments, to develop the cognitive aspects.
Music, Art, emotional, social do relate to cognitive development.
Now to your question: Your use of "compelling" is interesting. What is compelling in one community is not compelling in another. Saying what is compelling, or a compelling reason is fraught with values and politics. Sex Education, religious instruction, art, music, and values education are all in these areas which differing folks say is "compelling" or not.
As for myself, I think that music and art should be taught in school, as my experience teaching math and science is that some kids need that expression, it helps develop them and complements their cognitive functioning. Not all kids, but some.
Your teacher is probably looking for a "textbook" answer here, which is in your text probably number 2. But in reality, and reality is where we live, what is compelling is much more complex.

Bobpursley is right. What is compelling in one community -- or even one family --can be markedly different from what's in another.

Personally, I would choose number 1, but that's primarily because I've read a lot of educational research, as well as Plato's Republic, which indicate good connections between music and math, or music and language development.

You'll have to check your text or your class notes.

=)

I would definitely agree... music is a positive in developing math, coordination, language and many other aspect of mental development.

Whether parents "feel" it is important or not is not really relevant to its actual developmental importance.

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 154
asked by Chrissy

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. child development

    how you can assess a child’s knowledge? i also have another question. what are Gardner's intelligences? is it Linguistic intelligence ("word smart"): Logical-mathematical intelligence ("number/reasoning smart") Spatial

    asked by scooby on December 3, 2009
  2. creative play

    If a teacher has difficulty playing a musical instrument, he or she should: A. avoid teaching music. B. only teach music when a specialist is present. C. learn on the job by practicing in class. D. use one of many alternative ways

    asked by bev on June 27, 2017
  3. PSY

    Please help I get confused on the intelligence descriptions. Appropriately matching the profession with the their greatest area of intelligence. Intelligence Profession Kinesthetic Intelligence Ballet dancer Spatial Intelligence

    asked by Reedy on February 25, 2011
  4. creative play

    A child’s ability to mentally process the tonal aspects of rhythm and melody is part of: A. intrapersonal skills. B. musical intelligence. C. concentration. D. musical games. B?

    asked by bev on June 27, 2017
  5. Music and Movement

    A child-centered experience that connects music, movement,and language is: A. listening to the sounds of nature B. matching "sound shake" instruments C. visiting musicians in the community D. participating in musical storytelling

    asked by Chrissy on April 1, 2007
  6. music

    CHECK MY ANSWERS?? 1) the key signature does not A. tell which sharps and flats are in the key -----my answer B. appear in every staff in a musical composition C. explain weather the music is major or minor D. appear just after

    asked by meeya on March 17, 2016
  7. English

    one year ago 2. Read the following sentence from Betty Bonham Lies retelling of myth of Orpheus and Eurydice: "Orpheus's music was so compelling that even the ice-hard heart of Hades melted" What is the effect of the hyperbole in

    asked by Hello on May 15, 2016
  8. music

    what is an element in music There are a number of musical elements: rhythm, melody, dynamics, harmony, tempo, timbre, articulation, texture and form. You can find definitions for these by clicking on MUSIC under SUBJECTS on the

    asked by sasha on September 26, 2006
  9. stat

    Musical styles other than rock and pop are becoming more popular. A survey of college students finds that 34% like country music, 32% like gospel music, and 12% like both. What is the conditional probability (±0.01) that a

    asked by may on April 3, 2011
  10. statistics

    Musical styles other than rock and pop are becoming more popular. A survey of college students finds that 48% like country music, 30% like gospel music, and 10% like both. What is the conditional probability (±0.01) that a

    asked by Dee on March 21, 2012

More Similar Questions