Does Hawthorne like Hester Prynne? Explain. Before answering, be sure to look at his
comments about her in the novel, particularly his treatment of her in chapter 13, “Another View
of Hester.”
I don't have a copy of this book so I can't reread that chapter. What does Hawthorne say about her?
I do have a copy of the book, but what I think doesn't matter. What do YOU think?
To determine whether Hawthorne likes Hester Prynne, we need to examine his comments about her in the novel, particularly in chapter 13, "Another View of Hester."
Chapter 13 provides us with valuable insights into Hawthorne's perception of Hester. In this chapter, he describes the townspeople's changing perception of her after she had endured public shame and isolation for her adultery. Initially, the community condemned her and saw her as an embodiment of sin. However, as time passed, their attitudes softened, and they began to view her differently.
Hawthorne's portrayal of Hester in chapter 13 suggests a mixture of sympathy and admiration for her. He acknowledges her inner strength and resilience, as she bears the weight of her scarlet letter with dignity. He describes how Hester's beauty returned when she wore the letter, symbolizing her acceptance, and reveals that some even envied her for the freedom she found in accepting her sin.
However, it is worth noting that Hawthorne's portrayal of Hester is complex and multifaceted. While he acknowledges her strength, he also explores her flaws and moments of weakness. He highlights her temptation to show bitterness towards society and reveals her internal struggles as she grapples with her guilt and the consequences of her actions.
Overall, Hawthorne's treatment of Hester Prynne in the novel suggests a nuanced and complex view. While he appreciates her strength and resilience, he does not portray her as a flawless character. His portrayal showcases both her positive and negative qualities, reflecting a deeper understanding of human nature and the complexities of morality. Therefore, it can be said that Hawthorne has a complex and multi-dimensional view of Hester Prynne, neither strictly favorable nor unfavorable.