"Man is the only creature that consumes without producing. He does not give milk, he does not lay eggs, he is too weak to pull the plough, he cannot run fast enough to catch rabbits. Yet he is lord of all the animals. He sets them to work, he gives back to them the bare minimum that will prevent them from starving, and the rest he keeps for himself. Our labour tills the soil, and yet there is not one of us that owns more than his bare skin."—Old Major (a pig) from George Orwell's book Animal Farm
In the book Animal Farm, the animals on the farm revolt and form a new government. With which statement would the speaker most likely agree?
A) Animals should be given a share based on the work they do. The farm should be socialist.
B) A wise pig should make all the decisions on the farm. The farm should be an autocracy.
C) Every animal should have the right to vote. The farm should be a democracy.
D) Man should decide how to distribute things. The farm should be an oligarchy.
I think the answer is A.
Yes, A.
Thank you, Ms. Sue. You're awesome.
You're welcome. :-)
The statement made by Old Major, a pig in George Orwell's book Animal Farm, suggests that the animals on the farm are being exploited by humans and that they should have a fair share based on the work they do. This aligns with the concept of socialism, where resources are distributed based on the labor contributed by individuals.
To find the most likely agreement of the speaker, we need to closely analyze the given options.
Option A states that animals should be given a share based on the work they do, suggesting a fair and equal distribution of resources. This matches the sentiments expressed by Old Major in the quote provided.
Option B suggests that a wise pig should make all the decisions on the farm, indicating an autocratic rule. While Old Major does mention that the animals should revolt against human exploitation, he does not specifically advocate for a wise pig to make all the decisions on the farm.
Option C proposes that every animal should have the right to vote, suggesting a democratic system. Although this aligns with the idea of animals having a say in their governance, Old Major does not explicitly call for a system where every animal should vote.
Option D suggests that humans should decide how to distribute resources in an oligarchic system. This contradicts the sentiments expressed by Old Major as he criticizes human exploitation and advocates for a fair share for the animals.
Based on the analysis, it can be concluded that Option A, which advocates for a socialist system where animals are given a share based on the work they do, is the statement with which the speaker would most likely agree.