7. Suppose there are two possible income distributions in a society of ten people. In the first distribution, nine people have incomes of $30,000 and one person has an income of $10,000. In the second distribution, all ten people have incomes of $25,000.
a. If the society had the first income distribution, what would be the utilitarian argument for redistributing income?
The nine individuals have a higher utility than the one individual with the income of $10,000. So if for example a dollar was taken from the rich and given to the poor the utility of society as a whole would increase. This is because the poor person would have a higher utility from the dollar gained than the fall in utility from the rich people.

b. Which income distribution would Rawls consider more equitable? Explain.
I would think that the second distribution would be more equitable since Rawls would want equality.
c. Which income distribution would Nozick consider more equitable? Explain.

I would think that Nozick would consider the first distribution more equitable. Since Nozick would want individuals to a fair playing field but not concerned about the resulting distribution of income. So the second distribution of income is equal so the only option left is the first one.

What is your question regarding this situation?

I would like to know if my responses for each of the 3 questions is correct.

Your bottom line answers for Utilitarians and Rawls are correct. However, both views have exceptions which you should note in your final answer.

Nozick, on the other hand, is not bothered by income inequality as long as the process for generating the distribution is "fair." So, Nozick would not "prefer" either distribution. However, he would not advocate a redistribution process that moves from distribution a to distribution b.

Bottom line. your are on the right track; but your arguments need to be much more fully developed; certainly more than a single sentence for each.

  1. 👍
  2. 👎
  3. 👁

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. Social Studies

    Which of these phrases best summarizes legalism? A. Harsh laws are needed to keep order in society B. Moral values are the key to social order C. Citizens are capable of governing themselves D. Educating people leads to strong

  2. Budgets(Jobs)

    Which two things does a budget compare? A.Saving and interest B.Income and expenses C.Income and investments D.Expenses and expenditures B? Which of the following is a true statement about budgets? A.They encourage people to spend

  3. Math, Please Help!

    If 99 people had a mean income of $12,000, how much is the mean income increased by the addition of a single income of $200,000?

  4. math check answers

    1. A surplus is _____. (1 point) when you spend more than you have in income when you spend less than you have in income when you spend the same amount that you have in income another word for income 2. Suppose that your net

  1. statistics

    The statement 'The median of a distribution is approximately equal to the mean of the distribution' can be made true by adding which of the following: a. For all distributions b. only for symmetric, mound-shaped distributions c.

  2. Math

    Suppose that we wish to seat ten people, 5 men and 5 women, in a row of ten chairs. In how many ways can we seat the people with no restrictions?


    Suppose you are a typical person in the U.S. economy. You pay 4 percent of your income in state income tax and 15.3 percent of your labor earnings in federal payroll taxes (employer and employee shares combined). You also pay

  4. Economics

    Suppose that the Government runs a pension fund to which all workers must contribute. The employee contribution rate is 6.2 percent on the first $84,900 of income. All income in excess of $84,900 is not taxed for pension purposes.

  1. Math

    The mean annual income for people in a certain city (in thousands of dollars) is 47, with a standard deviation of 35. A pollster draws a sample of 54 people to interview. What is the probability that the sample mean income is less

  2. Economics

    6. The chapter uses the analogy of a "leaky bucket" to explain one constraint on the redistribution of income. a. What elements of the U.S. system for redistributing income create the leaks in the bucket? Be specific. b. Do you

  3. English

    One theme in The Giver, Chapter 1, is that a government with too much power can oppress its people. Which details does the author use to develop this theme? Select all that apply. A.The main character has a rebellious personality

  4. English

    In conclusion, the novel creates an oppressive environment where the men in the asylum are ruled by the Nurse. She uses her powers to make the men fearful, passive and emasculated victims. The Nurse wants a society of order,

You can view more similar questions or ask a new question.