Science - Chromatography

I performed a TLC of plant pigments in my lab class with a solvent of petroleum ether/ acetone (7:3) and used a silica gel plate.
It is expected that the most polar pigments (chlorophyll) will be located near the bottom and the carotenoids near top.
In my experiment, it was the exact opposite - the green bands (belonging to chlorophyll) were located on the top and the yellow bands (belonging to the carotenoids) were on the bottom.
Can any one explain where I could have gone wrong in my experiment? Is a possibility that there was water in the solvent?

Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

  1. 👍 0
  2. 👎 0
  3. 👁 96
  1. The solvent ratio is about right for separating chlorophyll and plant pigments on a TLC plate. When you say the chlorophyll was at the top do you mean with the solvent front? If this is the case the mixture is too polar. The carotenes (orange to yellow band) should be at the solvent front with a cellulose band behind this (say at an Rf of 0.8). Carotenoids (rather than carotene) however are polar molecules and may be stuck to the base line (Rf=0) as an orange-brown band. I can't give you any reference as this is from experience. I would have used methyl ethyl ketone (MEK)/Pet Ether or cyclohexanone/Pet Ether mixtures but you are probably limited by the lab experiment.

    The wikipedia reference below gives you the difference between carotene and carotenoid.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carotene

    1. 👍 0
    2. 👎 0
    posted by Dr Russ

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Response

Similar Questions

  1. chemistry- lab

    i need help locating a lab for regents chemistry. i have the data sheet but misplaced the rest of the lab. i know it's online somewhere, but i'm not sure which lab it is.. (what it is called). The data sheet has 3 charts on it, 1

    asked by Anonymous on March 15, 2009
  2. chemistry lab repost

    i need help locating a lab for regents chemistry. i have the data sheet but misplaced the rest of the lab. i know it's online somewhere, but i'm not sure which lab it is.. (what it is called). The data sheet has 3 charts on it, 1

    asked by please help! on March 15, 2009
  3. AP BIOLOGY LAB

    I am doing an ap biology lab on plant photosynthesis. It's specifically lab # 4 on plant pigments and photosynthesis and it's on question # 8 on Exercise 4B: Photosynthesis/ The Light Reaction. Identify the function of each of the

    asked by Roger on November 2, 2008
  4. Organic Chemistry Lab

    ISOLATION OF CHLOROPHYLL AND CAROTENOID PIGMENTS FROM SPINACH: What would happen to the Rf values of the pigments if you were to increase the relative concentration of acetone in the developing solvent ? I said the Rf values would

    asked by Chinma on March 21, 2010
  5. Purity

    The question asked is: Using yur results as a guide, comment on the purity of the material in the green and yellow bands. (from a TLC of spinach extraction pigments.) I'm not quite sure what they want here and my plate is in the

    asked by Sheryl on October 22, 2006
  6. Concentration increase

    Question: What would happen to the Rf values of the pigments if you were to increase the relative concntration of acetone in the developing solvent? Note: The development solvent used was 70% hexane - 30% acetone. My answer:

    asked by Sheryl on October 22, 2006
  7. science(chem)

    Consider the following errors that could be made when running the TLC. Indicate what should be done to correct the error. a) A 2 component mixture containing 1-octene and 1,4- dimethylbenzene gave only 1 spot with and Rf value of

    asked by ~christina~ on October 8, 2007
  8. Organic Chemistry Lab

    For the "ISOLATION OF CHLOROPHYLL AND CAROTENOID PIGMENTS FROM SPINACH" Lab we have to think about how we can correct the following if they were to occur: a.) When a two-component mixture containing 1-ocetone and

    asked by Jeanne on October 21, 2010
  9. Organic Chem

    What is the problem of spotting TOO much sample on a TLC plate initially? Also, why is it bad to have too much solvent in the TLC jar?

    asked by Jim on May 9, 2011
  10. Chemistry

    Consider the following errors that could be made when running TLC. Indicate what should be done to correct the error. a) a two-component mixture containing 1-octene and 1,4-dimethylbenzene gave only one spot with an Rf value of

    asked by Jordyn on October 3, 2010

More Similar Questions