What did John Smith and Anne Hutchinson have in common?

Both were thought of as troublemakers.

Both were governors upon arrival in America.

Both were Puritans who lived in New England. ***

Both had disagreements with the Puritans.

Nope.

To find the answer to this question, we can start by searching for information about John Smith and Anne Hutchinson. John Smith and Anne Hutchinson were historical figures who lived during the early colonial period of America. John Smith was an English explorer and early leader of the Jamestown Colony, while Anne Hutchinson was a religious dissenter who settled in the Massachusetts Bay Colony.

Given the options provided, we can evaluate each statement to determine which is true.

Statement 1: Both were thought of as troublemakers.
Both John Smith and Anne Hutchinson faced opposition and conflict with the authorities of their time. John Smith had strained relationships with some members of the Jamestown Colony due to his leadership style, and Anne Hutchinson was famously expelled from the Massachusetts Bay Colony for challenging the religious doctrine of the Puritans. Therefore, this statement is true for both individuals.

Statement 2: Both were governors upon arrival in America.
This statement is not accurate for either John Smith or Anne Hutchinson. John Smith was never a governor; rather, he held various leadership roles within the Jamestown Colony. Anne Hutchinson also did not serve as a governor upon her arrival in America. Instead, she became a prominent figure and spiritual leader within the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Therefore, this statement is incorrect for both individuals.

Statement 3: Both were Puritans who lived in New England.
This statement is true for both John Smith and Anne Hutchinson. John Smith was not a Puritan himself, but Anne Hutchinson was a devout Puritan. Both individuals lived in New England during the colonial period, with John Smith primarily associated with the Virginia colony and Anne Hutchinson residing in the Massachusetts Bay Colony.

Statement 4: Both had disagreements with the Puritans.
This statement is true for both John Smith and Anne Hutchinson. While John Smith did not have direct conflicts with the Puritans, he had disagreements and strained relationships with other leaders and settlers during his time in Jamestown. Anne Hutchinson, on the other hand, openly challenged the religious doctrines and leadership of the Puritans in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, leading to her eventual banishment.

Based on the evaluation of the statements, the correct answer is: "Both were Puritans who lived in New England."