how is "young love" by andrew marvell and "of holiness of life" by john bunyan, both the same in politcal, poetic and thematic sense?
thank you!
I think it's a bit of a stretch to compare the two. Bunyan is rejecting all influences except faith in the Christian God. Marvell is rejecting influences, even the Crown (the monarch or government), into the innocence of pure love, which he contends must rule the heart. So both reject artificial, exterior influences over something deeply and personally held. Marvell is not talking about religion as Bunyan is, but the themes are somewhat similar. Do you agree?
i kind of understand. but what does reject artificial exterior means?
To determine how "Young Love" by Andrew Marvell and "Of Holiness of Life" by John Bunyan are similar in the political, poetic, and thematic sense, we need to analyze the content and context of both poems.
1. Political Sense:
To understand the political context, we need to examine any references or allusions to political events or ideologies in the poems. Look for any direct or indirect commentary on political power, authority, or societal structures. Consider whether the poems convey any political opinions or criticize the existing political order.
For "Young Love" by Andrew Marvell, a renowned metaphysical poet, there is no explicit political theme or reference present in the poem. It primarily focuses on the themes of love and time. As such, it might not be directly comparable to "Of Holiness of Life" by John Bunyan in terms of the political sense, as Bunyan was known for his strong religious and political beliefs.
2. Poetic Sense:
Consider the poetic elements employed in both poems, including the use of imagery, figurative language (such as metaphors and similes), rhyme scheme, meter, and structure. Analyze the tone, style, and overall aesthetic of the poems. Look for any similarities or differences in their use of poetic devices.
Unfortunately, without the full text of "Young Love," it is challenging to provide a detailed analysis of its poetic elements and compare them with "Of Holiness of Life." However, generally, both Marvell and Bunyan were skilled poets who used vivid imagery and employed figurative language to convey their ideas effectively.
3. Thematic Sense:
Examine the underlying themes or messages of the poems. Determine what philosophical, moral, or universal concepts both poems explore. Look for commonalities or overlapping themes, such as love, morality, spirituality, human experience, or the passage of time.
While the specific themes of "Young Love" cannot be determined without the complete poem, it is possible to discuss the thematic sense of "Of Holiness of Life" by John Bunyan. This religious poem emphasizes the importance of leading a holy and righteous life, aligning with Bunyan's Christian beliefs. It reflects his understanding of moral conduct and the pursuit of spiritual salvation.
In summary, without complete information about "Young Love" by Andrew Marvell, it is challenging to draw direct comparisons between the two poems in the political, poetic, and thematic sense. However, by analyzing their content and context, including political references (if present), poetic elements, and underlying themes, you can identify any similarities or differences that might exist.