1. Reread the final paragraph of the speech of Pontiac (page 445) and the closing lines of Logan’s message, as set down by Jefferson (page 450). Between oral discourse and written discourse, what are the crucial differences in reaching and holding the attention of an audience? How does each passage reflect its provenance as spoken literature rather than as words created for print?
I don't see how we can help you since we don't have access to your assigned materials.
Native American : Contact and Conflict
Is it this?
http://cuzcocatherine.wordpress.com/2012/03/14/native-americans-contact-and-conflict/
To analyze the differences in reaching and holding the attention of an audience between oral discourse and written discourse, we need to examine the final paragraph of Pontiac's speech on page 445 and the closing lines of Logan's message as noted by Jefferson on page 450. These passages will show how each form of literature reflects its provenance as spoken literature rather than words created for print. Let's look at each passage individually:
1. Pontiac's Speech:
To begin, reread the final paragraph of Pontiac's speech on page 445. This speech represents oral discourse, which means it was originally delivered as an spoken address rather than written specifically for print. As you read the paragraph, pay attention to the elements that indicate its oral origins. These might include characteristics like rhythmic language, repetition, figurative language, or direct audience address. Identify any such elements in the paragraph.
Once you've identified these elements, consider how they contribute to the oratorical nature of the passage. Think about how they might help engage and captivate the attention of the audience when delivered orally. Reflect on the emotional appeal and persuasive techniques at play, as oral discourse often relies on such strategies to connect with the audience.
2. Logan's Message:
Next, let's examine the closing lines of Logan's message as recorded by Jefferson on page 450. This passage represents written discourse, created specifically for print rather than for live oral delivery. As you read this portion, look for characteristics that reflect its nature as written literature. This may include features such as a more formal tone, structured organization, complex syntax, precise diction, or literary devices primarily used in written form.
Consider how these elements reflect the distinct nature of written discourse. Ponder their ability to hold the attention of a reader, who has time to reflect and interpret the words without the immediate presence of the speaker. Analyze how the message relies on the written medium to convey its meaning effectively.
By comparing these two passages, you can identify the crucial differences in how oral discourse and written discourse capture and maintain audience attention. Look for distinct stylistic, linguistic, and rhetorical features that exemplify the inherent nature of each medium. In doing so, you will gain a deeper understanding of how oral and written literature engage their respective audiences.