posted by .

This question refers to the ethical issue of giving organ transplants to prisoners who have been sentenced to prison for the commission of crimes. From a utilitarian perspective, which of the following is an argument against allowing prisoners to receive organ transplants?

Prisoners have violated the rules of society and, therefore, that have no moral right to receive benefits from society.

It would be better for society to allocate scarce organs to non-prisoners who could contribute more to society than prisoners could contribute.

After they have served their punishment for their crimes, prisoners will be entitled to be treated as ends in themselves.

There is a moral duty of autonomy for prisoners to choose to receive organ transplants, but that moral duty is outweighed by the moral duty of justice.

I believe its D

  • Ethics -

    I disagree. That's not a utilitarian point of view.

  • Ethics -

    C makes more of a applied anwser since its to be entitled to be treated as ends in themselves

  • Ethics -

    Actually from a maximum utility benefit/cost point of view, I should think B would be the winner.

  • Ethics -

    I agree with you, Damon.

Respond to this Question

First Name

School Subject

Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. criminal justice

    After some recent incidents involving guard mistreatment of prisoners at your local correctional institution, you have been tasked to draft a sample standard operating procedure (SOP) for guard behavior. Create an SOP that addresses …
  2. social problems

    Dr.Rivera and Dr. Harris want to conduct research to determine whether training prisoners in computer skills during incarceration will reduce recidivism.The researchers plan to compare a group of prisoners who received the training …
  3. English

    Writeacher, can you help me check these sentences?
  4. English

    I still have a few questions on the listening comprehension. Thank you. 1) "Amnesty works for the release of ‘Prisoners of Conscience’- men, women and children imprisoned anywhere for their beliefs, colour, sex, ethnic origin, …
  5. English

    I left out two sentences because I'm finding it difficult to send you my post all together. 3) It is an organization that will only be satisfied when it has become redundant. Does this sentence mean that it will go on working until …
  6. Sociology

    Identify, specifically, the ethical issue and the ethical problems it presents. Drawing on various sources, explain how one of the classical theories (utilitarianism, deontology, virtue ethics) would resolve the problem. Then, contrast …
  7. Social Studies

    1. Which action that occurred ruing the Battle of Chickamauga made it a Confederate victory?
  8. Social Studies

    Please check my answers 1. There were two different groups in the elite planter class. What distinguished these groups?
  9. stats

    In 1997, the U.S. population was approximately 266,572,000 people. At the rate of 440 prisoners per 100,000 population, about how many prisoners were in the system?
  10. English

    What does Wiesel’s description of his hatred of the bells help you infer from the memoir?

More Similar Questions