Business Law II

posted by .

I ask a friend to watch my bike while I go shopping, and the bike gets stolen. I can sue my friend for damages but only if I can prove that my friend was:
grossly negligent, or failed to exercise at least slight care, or failed to exercise reasonable care. Which one would be the best answer, if this is all the details of the situation.

  • Business Law II -

    Well, since I can't remember the answer from the Bar Exam, let's use the process of elimination.

    "Slight care" is not a legal standard under any circumstances, so that's not the answer. Cancel out "slight care."

    The first question to ask to resolve this question is what "duty of care," if any, did the friend from whom the bike was stolen owe to the friend who was the owner of the bike. Common law assigns a "duty of care" based on the relationship between the people, e.g. as between a hotel owner and a hotel guest, or a storage company and the person storing his goods there.

    "duty of care n.: a requirement that a person act toward others and the public with watchfulness, attention, caution and prudence that a reasonable person in the circumstances would. If a person's actions do not meet this standard of care, then the acts are considered negligent, and any damages resulting may be claimed in a lawsuit for negligence.

    Here we have a bailor/bailee relationship between the boy who asked someone to hold the bike (the "bailor") and the friend who held the bike (the "bailee").

    "When a bailor receives the sole benefit from the bailment, the bailee has a lesser duty to care for the property and is financially responsible only if he or she has been grossly negligent or has acted in bad faith in taking care of the property. FreeDictionary

    The fact that you're not PAYING your friend to watch your bike, and your friend did not ask to borrow your bike would both be reasons for a court not to require him to exercise that much care.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Personal injury/ laws

    i have question about me and my friend suppose me and my friend (soura) are hinking in colorado mountains, there is dog by its owner, who is from Wyoming, bites my friend caused him injury. I want my friend to sue the owner of dog, …
  2. Algebra I

    1. A Passenger train's speed is 60mi/h and a freight train's speed is 40mi/h. The passenger train travels the same distance in 1.5 h less time than the freight train. How long does each train take to make the trip?
  3. algebra 1

    lois rode her bike to visit a friend. She traveled at 10 miles an hour. While she was there it began to rain. Her friend drove her home at 25 miles per hour. Lois took 1.5 hours longer to go to a friends then to return home. How many …
  4. physics

    you walk up the aisle in a bus moving 10m/sec and a seated friend you are walking 1.5m/sec. another friend who just got off the bus standing there waving at you says you are moving 11.5m/sec.and the stalker friend riding his bike next …
  5. physics

    a bicyclist is finishing his repair of a flat tire when a friend rides by at 3.5 m/s. two seconds later, the bicyclist hops on his bike and accelerates at 2.4 m/s^2 until he catches his friend?
  6. physics( PLEASE READ)

    a bicyclist is finishing his repair of a flat tire when a friend rides by at 3.5 m/s. two seconds later, the bicyclist hops on his bike and accelerates at 2.4 m/s^2 until he catches his friend?
  7. phyics (PLEASE PLEASE READ)

    a bicyclist is finishing his repair of a flat tire when a friend rides by at 3.5 m/s. two seconds later, the bicyclist hops on his bike and accelerates at 2.4 m/s^2 until he catches his friend?
  8. Health (Ms. Sue)

    After school, your friend asks you to give him a lift home on your bike. What would you tell your friend?
  9. Health

    what should you refrain from doing while helping a friend or family member who is being abused?
  10. ED TECH Ms Sue Check Answer

    What is the rhyme scheme of the following poem?

More Similar Questions