Virtue Ethics-College Level

posted by .

I need help in understanding what the viewpoint would be of a virtue ethicist in deciding who should receive a liver transplant. There are 5 candidates:
Bob- is 40 years old unemployed, homeless with a severe drinking problem and a criminal record.He was the first to sign up for the transplant
Joe- is 42 years old, extremely wealthy business man. He was the last to sign up for the transplant. he has offered a $100 million donation to the hospital.
Sarah- 26 years old single mother of 6 school aged children
Karen- 60 years old renown Noble Prize winning medical researcher currently working on AIDS research.
Chris- 8 years old who is the sickest of the 5 and will more than likely die within a week without the transplant.
I think that my mind keeps going back to a consequentialist viewpoint on this. I think that Bob would be out for certain because his character is not one of virtue and his illness is caused by his irresponsible unhealthy extreme lifestyle. He also would not have the social support needed for his immuno-suppressant follow up care. I also think that a virtue ethicist would think that Sarah should not be a recipient because she may have problems with follow up care as well because of the 6 school aged children and only 1 income. How will she be able to contribute tangibly to society with the rigorous after care that is needed after a transplant. I am not sure if I am on the right path or not and I have no idea about the 2 candidates. My first thought is to go with the 8 year old because he has the longest life ahead of him to be able to contribute to the community and society as a virtuous human being.
Please help!!

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. English

    Three examples of how virtue may be used in everyday life?
  2. Ethics

    Please help with an assignment: I need to pick 5 articles from the Washington post, each addressing a moral issue. Each essay needs to have one moral issue question based on the following topics. 1. utilitarianism 2. Moral Rights 3. …
  3. college soc 120

    utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics of gay marriage
  4. Ethics

    I need help in understanding what the viewpoint would be of a virtue ethicist in deciding who should receive a liver transplant. There are 5 candidates: Bob- is 40 years old unemployed, homeless with a severe drinking problem and a …
  5. ETHICS

    a 350- to 700-word essay comparing the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. Include the following in your essay: • A description of the differences in how each theory addresses …
  6. Soc 120

    3. Utilitarians evaluate the morality of an act by examining the consequences of the act. the person carrying out the act. the feelings of the person carrying out the act. the amount of pain generated by the act. 4. Logic will examine …
  7. Psychology

    I need someone to review my five answers. Inform me if I am correct with my choices as well as correct me if I answered any of them wrong. Thank you! 1) If one wishes to become a professional counselor and has completed the educational …
  8. Ethics in Criminal Justice

    Which of the following frameworks would be most likely to justify convicting an innocent person?
  9. Ethisc/Criminal Justice

    Which of the following frameworks would be most likely to justify convicting an innocent person?
  10. ethics

    Approaching moral issues and ethical situations from each of the major ethical frameworks means deciding with duties or with any of the following EXCEPT: A. deciding with consequences. B. deciding with virtue C. deciding with care. …

More Similar Questions