posted by .

Since the oxidation number of Chromium is +3, and the oxidation number of Silicon is -4. Why is the chemical formula for Chromium III Silicide Cr3Si2?

Can somebody please explain to me please???????THANKS A LOT!!!

  • Chemistry -

    The best answer I can give is that although the oxidation number for Cr is +3 in most of its compounds and the oxidation number for Si, in most of its compounds is (I think +4 in SiO2, SiCl4, etc), the oxidation number for Si is not +4 (or -4) in Cr3Si2. In Cr3Si2, if we call Cr +3, then each Si is -4.5.
    Oxidation numbers are nothing more than a set of man-made rules and is really a book keeping procedure to keep up with loss and gain of electrons. Let me show you what I mean.
    CN^- ==> CNO^-
    Suppose we call C+4, then N is -5 on the left and on the right it is (+4C, -2 for O, so N is -3) So the N atom changed from -5 to -3 which is a loss of 2 electrons . But suppose I'm on a test and forgot the rules. Simple. I make up my own.
    Let's call C+19. then
    CN^- gives C +19 and N must be -20.
    In CNO^-, C is +19, O is -2, so N must be -18. The nitrogen atom changed from -20 to -18 which is a loss of 2 electrons.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions


    is the oxidation number for platinum larger than the oxidation number for osmium?
  2. chemistry

    The oxidation number of chromium (Cr) in the dichromate ion (Cr2O72-) is A. +2 B. +4 C. +6 D. +7 E. -2
  3. Chemistry

    In a reaction, 39.5 g of chromium(III) oxide reacts with 14.0 g of aluminum to produce chromium and aluminum oxide. If 27.0 g of chromium is produced, what mass of aluminum oxide is produced?
  4. Chemistry

    What is the oxidation number of chromium in K2Cr2O7?
  5. Chemistry(Please check)

    What is the oxidation number of chromium in K2Cr2O7 so k=+1 (2) = 2 O=-2(7) = -14 2x + 1 +(-14) = 0 2x-12=0 x=6 so Cr is 6 Is this correct?
  6. chemistry

    2 questions please: The highest positive oxidation number that chlorine can exhibit an any compound is +7, whereas its most negative oxidation number is -1. Write the electron configuration of chlorine and explain why these are limiting …
  7. Chem

    Sort the following chromium compounds by whether the cation is chromium(II) or chromium(III). Cr2S3, Cr3P2, Crl3, CrO, CrBr2, CrN. How would I solve this?
  8. chemistry

    Which statement best describes the oxidation numbers of the atoms found in magnesium chloride?
  9. Chemistry

    The two most common oxidation states are Cr(III) and Cr(VI). Balance the following oxidation-reduction equations that involve one of these oxidation states of chromium. Assume that the reactions occur in acidic solution. A. Cr(s) + …
  10. chemistry

    Write the oxidation and reduction half-reactions for a silver-chromium voltaic cell. Identify the anode, cathode, and the direction of electron flow. Ag+ + e-  Ag Cr  Cr2+ + 2e- or Cr  Cr3+ + 3e- ?

More Similar Questions