mathpremises
posted by donovan .
A bit confused with this one: Is the argument correct? if not explain why it's not and change the minor premise to make it correct:
All NBA basketball players are over 5ft. tall
Russell is 6ft tall
Therefore, Russell plays in the NBA
Thanks!

mathpremises 
donovan
I meant to add my thoughts: I think it is incorrect because of an inverse problem. To make it correct I would write it as:
All NBA basketball players are over 5ft tall
Russell is an NBA player
Therefore, Russell is over 6ft tall. 
mathpremises 
MathMate
The first post has made a wrong conclusion. (p>q and q>p are different propositinos)
The second conclusion is correct. 
mathpremises 
donovan
thank you!

mathpremises 
MathMate
You're welcome!
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

critical thinking
is this an example of an invalid argument All crows are black John is black Therefor, John is a crow. is this an example of a unsound argument All dogs are black Lassie is a dog Lassie is a cat Please tell me if this is right. You're … 
math
Determine whether the following argument is correct. If itâ€™s not correct, explain what is wrong with the argument and change the minor premise to make a correct argument. If a triangle is equilateral, then it has three equal sides. … 
Geometry... Please help soon!
Write four arguments that meet the following criteria: Argument 1: The argument has a false premise, but follows good logic. Argument 2: The argument has true premises, but follows poor logic, leading to a false conclusion. Argument … 
physics
An aboveground pool is 5ft tall with a diameter of 40 ft is filled with water in 50 minutes. How long will it take to fill an aboveground pool that is 6ft tall with a diameter of 36 ft? 
physics
An aboveground pool is 5ft tall with a diameter of 40 ft is filled with water in 50 minutes. How long will it take to fill an aboveground pool that is 6ft tall with a diameter of 36 ft? 
physics
An aboveground pool is 5ft tall with a diameter of 40 ft is filled with water in 50 minutes. How long will it take to fill an aboveground pool that is 6ft tall with a diameter of 36 ft? 
math
Determine whether the following argument is correct. If it's not correct, explain what is wrong with ther argument and change the minor premise to make a correct argument. If a triangle is equilateral, then it has three equal sides. … 
Math
Number Sense Fabio said that there are 3 times as many people on a basketball team as on a tennis team. Is he correct? 
Math
Number Sense Fabio said that there are 3 times as many people on a basketball team as on a tennis team. Is he correct? 
Math
5. What is the contrapositive of the following conditional: "If a student plays basketball, then the student is over 6 feet tall." A If a student is over 6 feet tall then the student plays basketball. B  IF a student is not over …