English

posted by .

1. He has bought a ring.
1-1. He bought a ring and has it now.

(#1 means #1-1, right? What about the following?)

2. You have smelled my cakes.
2-1. You smelled my cakes and you are satisfied with the smell now.

3. I haven't stolen your cakes.
3-1. I didn't steal you cakes and don't have them now.

4. I haven't touched your cakes.
4-1. I didn't touch your cakes and don't have them now.

5. I haven't stolen anything.
5-1. I didn't steal anything and don't have it now.

6. This traveler has enjoyed the smell.
6-1. This traveler enjoyed the smell and are stisfied with it now.

7. I've spent all my money on my journey.
7-1. I spent all my money on my journey and don't have any money now.

8. He has used only the smell.
8-1. He used only the smell and is satisfied with it now.

(Is each pair the same from #2 to #8? Does each sentence, containing the have/has + pp structure, have the same meaning? Would you chek them, please? Thank you.)

  • English -

    1 and 1-1 mean the same and are fine.

    2 and 2-1 mean about the same thing, but I'd remove the words "with the smell" toward the end of 2-1.

    3 and 3-1 mean about the same thing, yes.

    4 and 4-1 mean the same thing.

    5 and 5-1 -- hmmm. I think I'd delete "and don't have it now" from the second sentence; that phrasing implies that you know what was stolen and could be lying!!

    6 is fine; 6-1 is OK, but needs corrections -- should be "is satisfied" (watch subject/verb agreement and spelling, too).

    7 and 7-1 are fine.

    8 and 8-1 don't make sense to me. What did he use the smell for?

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. math

    2 cakes are divided into 10 = pieces! there is a ring in one of the 10 slices in each cake. what is the probability that there is no ring in the first slice that you take in both cakes?
  2. English

    1. You have smelled my cakes. 2. I haven't stolen your cakes. (What does each present perfect tense mean?
  3. English

    1. What do you think the judge did? He made the greedy baker hear the sound of three gold coins. By doing that, he paid for the smell of delicious cakes that the poor traveler used. Do you agree with the judge's decision or not?
  4. maths

    wayen bought an ring for tracy the total cost of the ring was £360 plus VAT at 20& what is the cost of the ring ?
  5. homework math

    For every 20 cakes ordered from Barry's Bakery, 8 cakes ordered are chocolate. Which proportion can be used to determine x, the total number of cakes ordered from the bakery when 30 chocolate cakes have been ordered?
  6. maths

    there are 7 children standing in a line ,not all of whom have the same number of cakes with them, if the first child distributes his cakes to the remaining six children such that he doubles their respective no.of cakes ,then he will …
  7. math

    Mohan and Sohan went to a bakery shop. Mohan bought 6 puffs, four burgers and three cakes and used up all the money he had. Sohan bought three puffs, eight burgers and six cakes and spent 20% more than Mohan. What percent of his money …
  8. Math

    The baker made 258 cakes.100 cakes were bought of a party.how many cakes were left?
  9. math

    There are ten children standing in the line, not all of whom have the same number of cakes with them. If the first child distributes his cakes to the remaining six children such that he doubles their respective number of cakes, then …
  10. Math

    Amy bought a diamond ring for $6,000. If the value of the ring increases at a constant rate of 5.8% per year, how much will the ring be worth in twenty-one years?

More Similar Questions