Critical Thinking

posted by .

All flies are winged creatures.
All butterflies are winged creatures
Therefore, all butterflies are flies

I believe this is an invalid syllogism, not 100% sure. Can you explain why it would be valid or invalid please

  • Critical Thinking -

    A valid syllogism is:

    All A are B
    C is A
    therefore
    (since C is A and all A are B)
    C is B

    The non-syllogism above is:

    All A are B
    All C are B
    Therefore all A are B.

    Erm, no.

    Spot the difference. Here's one of the same form:

    All fish are animals
    All birds are animals
    Therefore all fish are birds.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. critical thinking

    is this an example of an invalid argument All crows are black John is black Therefor, John is a crow. is this an example of a unsound argument All dogs are black Lassie is a dog Lassie is a cat Please tell me if this is right. You're …
  2. math

    Determine if the argument is valid or invalid. Give a reason to justify answer. If it is cold, then you need a coat. You do not need a coat. It is not cold. (Points : 2) Valid by the law of detachment Valid by the law of contraposition …
  3. science**

    many birds eat butterflies for food. however, the monarch butterfly has a bad taste and is therefore avoided by birds. the viceroy butterfly looks very much like monarch butterfly, but it does not taste bad to the birds. tiger swallowtail …
  4. English

    I am a bit stumped here. Working on syllogisms. To be a valid syllogism, the conclusion must be proven by the reasons. We are to decide if te following are valid or invalid. 1. All zebras are striped animals. No zebras are polar bears. …
  5. Math-Syllogism valid?

    Some snakes are poisonous. A rattlesnake is a snake. Therefore: a rattlesnake is poisonous. Is syllogism valid or invalid?
  6. Algebra

    The ratio of North American butterflies to South American butterflies is 5:3. The ratio to South American butterflies to European butterflies is 3:2. There are 30 North American butterflies at the butterfly park. Question A. How many …
  7. math:order of operation

    TWO PART Ellen is playing a video game in which she captures butterflies. There are 3 butterflies onscreen, but the number of butterflies doubles every minute. After 4 minutes, she was able to capture 7 of the butterflies. A)LOOK FOR …
  8. Math

    If a rectangle has four congruent sides, it is a square. A square has perpendicular diagonals. Conclusion: A rectangle has diagonals that are always perpendicular. Which of the following is correct The conclusion is valid by the law …
  9. Geometry

    Determine whether the statement (3) follows from statement (1) and (2) by the law of detachment or the law of syllogism. If it does, state which law was used. If it does not, write invalid. (1) if you study you will be smart (2) if …
  10. Math

    The ratio of North American butterflies to South American butterflies at a butterfly park is 5:3. The ratio of South American butterflies to European butterflies is 3:2. There are 30 North American butterflies at the butterfly park. …

More Similar Questions