Dr.Bob, response to your reply to last answer

posted by .

Sorry, I didn't see this.
Actually you have only one mixture; it happens to have two components. There is a more or less standard procedure for separating complete unknowns (that's where you know nothing about it) and if you know nothing about it that is where you start. You have either had such a procedure already or you will be given one soon. Or consult a standard organic qualitative analysis book to see how to do it. I doubt, at the level you are, that anyone would expect you to go through the entire procedure. I'll bet that you will be give some directions as well as some glimmer of information that will help you determione what to do. I also expect you will be given more than enough sample to allow you to run a number of tests. I know I've talked in general terms, only, but with nothing more to go on, that's about the best I can do.
The thing is that we are expected to come up with the whole procedure ourselves, and present that for approval. We haven't had any separation techniques except in organic (involving distillation), and this is an instrumental lab class. We have always been given pure samples that are not mixed, to work with. We are also advised to give ourselves 3 months to do the whole thing. What I described before with knowing the sample identity in a mix and finding the concentrations through UV Spec, and HPLC is the only thing that we have learned recently.
The thing is that we mostly work with instruments and solution preparation now and not really what I did in Quant, with the whole full scale reaction experiments. It's an odd situation there, especially since there's no set up for recrystalization or filtering and etc. Where I am now, we just mostly rely on instruments to determine unknown identities, which is why I am confused here.
I guess I'll just have to find an organic quantative anaylsis book and somehow come up with a proposal. I guess the Skoog book isn't adequate for this sort of situation. Or I just hope I get an unknown with one compound in it, but how would I know that, if the powder could be white for both compounds? (and mixed)

Thanks for giving me a direction to head in, Dr.Bob.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. DanH-Algebra 1

    Solve the system of equations using the Addition method. 2a + 3b = -1 3a + 5b = -2 Margie: Roger's answer below is correct. If you don't understand it, please try and tell us what you don't understand. He makes it sound so strange …
  2. Chemistry

    I saw that article on Google - that is actually how I got the idea to sublimate the naphthalene. But thank you for the suggestion! It makes me feel much more confident to know that I am on the right track! Thank you! We have a lab …
  3. science one more

    Which ones apply to a heterogeneous mixture?
  4. chemistry- Dr.Bob, can you help me out please?

    If I had two unknown chemicals (in solid form) mixed together, how could I go about identifying the individual components of the mixture?
  5. pre lab Q on chromatography

    suppose that there are two components, A and B, in a mixture. The chemical affinity of A for the stationary pahse is less than that of B and the chemical affinity of A for the mobile phase is greater than that of B. If the mixture …
  6. science

    i have a quesion about an experiment of Separating a Mixture of Nails, Salt, Sand, Oil and water. 1) what components did you separate from the mixture first?
  7. chemistry

    I know I posted this and it got a response, but unfortunately for me the reponse has got me confused, sorry Bob. Fe3+ (aq), Ca2+ (aq) and Ba2+ are all present in the same solution. Fully describe a procedure whereby you could separate …
  8. Physics please help!

    I have tried to work this one out and really can't get it. We have two carts that have magnets to keep them from touching. One cart is initially at rest and we push the second cart towards it. Because the two carts will not actually …
  9. Separation processes

    Hi, the question is: In an equilibrium diagram for a binary mixture, what does it mean for distillation if the relative volatility is low?
  10. Maths

    Tom has more money than Bob. If Tom gave Bob R20 , they would have the same amount. While if Bob gave Tom R22 , Tome would then have twice as much as Bob. How much does each one actually have?

More Similar Questions