i know i've asked this question before but i never get a clear response..
i don't want the answer, but pleeeaes give me some information or some sites that have GOOD information.
Discuss how both the North and South defended their position on the question of secession by tracing the history of their argument?
If you tell us what you've found so far in your book, we'll be glad to add to that information.
I suggest you make two lists. One with the reasons the South gave for seceeding and the other for the reasons the North gave for opposing secession.
You'll also need to include dates, when available, for these arguments.
To understand how both the North and South defended their positions on the question of secession, it is essential to trace the historical context and arguments put forth by each side. Here is a breakdown of the key points to consider:
1. North's Position:
- The North believed that secession was unconstitutional and illegal. They argued that the United States was a perpetual union, founded on the principle of popular sovereignty, and secession threatened the stability and integrity of the nation.
- They emphasized that the Constitution explicitly granted power to the federal government, which included the authority to prevent secession.
- Advocates of the Union argued that preserving the United States was crucial for the preservation of democracy, economic growth, and individual liberty.
- The Emancipation Proclamation and the eventual focus on ending slavery became central to the Northern cause during the Civil War.
2. South's Position:
- The South maintained that secession was a legitimate and constitutional response to perceived infringements on states' rights and threats to their economic and social interests.
- They argued that the states voluntarily entered into the union and retained their sovereignty. Therefore, they had the right to withdraw from the union if they felt their rights were being violated.
- Southerners contended that the federal government had overstepped its constitutional boundaries, particularly through anti-slavery measures like the Missouri Compromise and the Fugitive Slave Act.
- The South heavily relied on its agrarian economy, which heavily relied on slave labor, and saw the abolitionist movement as a direct threat to their way of life.
To delve deeper into this topic and find more comprehensive information, here are some recommended resources:
1. Library of Congress: "The South Secedes": A detailed overview of the events leading up to secession, including primary source documents, photographs, and maps.
- Website: www.loc.gov/rr/program/bib/ourdocs/Secession.html
2. National Park Service: "Civil War Trust": Provides a wealth of information about the Civil War, including the positions of both the North and South regarding secession.
- Website: www.civilwar.org/learn/civil-war/battles
3. History.com: "Secession": Offers an in-depth exploration of the causes and consequences of secession, including various perspectives from both the North and South.
- Website: www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/secession
Remember to critically evaluate the sources, cross-reference information, and consult reputable academic resources, books, and scholarly articles to gain a well-rounded understanding of this historical topic.