Post a New Question

French-Mme SraJMcGin

posted by .

Bonjour,
I just want to make absolutely sure that I now properly understand this:
I know how to use negation in a simple sentence. No problem.
I still am a bit shaky on sentences with two verbs; if I understood you correctly, then when a negative sentence has two verbs, both parts of the negative go before the verb that is in the infinitive.
Thus, if I wanted to say: "you cannot give us an apple", I would say:
"vous pouvez ne pas nous donner une pomme" IS THAT CORRECT???
(earlier I would have put it this way "vous ne pouvez pas nous donner une pomme" which, according to what I think you said, would be incorrect.)
Thank you once again for your help and clarification.

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    negative form : ne + verbe conjugué + pas/plus....
    or
    ne + pas/plus ... + verbe à l'infinitif

    so in your first sentence, the negative form refers to the verb "donner" = not to give
    in your second sentence, the negative form refers to the verb "pouvoir" = cannot

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    Let's hope it's clear now to you. You must determine if it is the "object" of the infinitive, as in the first example or of the main/conjugated verb. Therefore:
    vous ne pouvez pas nous donner une pomme. = you CAN'T (can not) is the more likely choice.

    Mme

    Which sounds better to you: You are able not to give us OR You are not able to give us. Hopefully it's now easy to tell?

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    but

    vous pouvez ne pas nous donner une pomme is correct too but

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    True, but he probably didn't mean that, true?

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    yes,you're right

  • French-Mme SraJMcGin -

    Merci beaucoup Mme SraJMcGin et mk-tintin

Answer This Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Related Questions

More Related Questions

Post a New Question