Math

posted by .

What is wrong with the following proof. You must explain your answer in words.
a>3
3a>3(3)
3a-a^2>9-a^2
a(3-a)>(3-a)(3+a)
a>3+a
0>3
the problem with the proof is that the fourth step needs the sign to be reverse...but why?
i looked at step 3 and there is nothing negative to reverse the sigh for...

  • Math -

    From the first statement, a must be a positive number. In fact, it must exceed 3. (This is very important later). The second and third statements are correct, since you are either multiplying by positive numbers or just factoring. The fourth statement is incorrect because 3-a is a negative number.The directon of the > sign must change.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Abstract Algebra

    If 2^n>n^2 and n>5, then 2^n+1>(n+1)^2 Proof: Assuming that 2^n>n^2 then I can say that 2*2^2>2*n^2 = 2^n+1>2n^2 If I can show that 2n^2>(n+1)^2 then I will be done by transitivity. So 2n^2>(n+1)^2?
  2. geometry

    Give the reason for the step taken from a proof. <1 and <2 are a linear pair given m<1 + m<2 = 180* ?
  3. communication

    In general, thesis or central idea is supported by claims; claims are supported by proof; and A.proof is supported by development,including details and examples B.proof is supported by the specific purpose C.proof is supported by solutions …
  4. math

    A bourbon that is 51-proof is 25.5% alcohol by volume while one that is 82-proof is 41% alcohol by volume. How many liters of 51 proof bourbon must be mixed with 1.0-L of 82 proof bourbon to produce a 66 proof bourbon?
  5. Math

    Please help me with this problem: A bourbon that is 51 proof is 25.5% alcohol by volume while one that is 82 proof is 41% alcohol. How many liters of 51 proof bourbon must be mixed with 1.0 L of 82 proof bourbon to produce a 66 proof …
  6. college math

    I posted this problem earlier, but I still can't figure it out. It is for extra credit. I was hoping if someone could please solve it. I would greatly appreciate it. A bourbon that is 51 proof is 25.5% alcohol by vol. while one that …
  7. Philosophy

    I need help with this proof for my philosophy class. This proof is supposed to be done via indirect proof or conditional proof, so it is supposed to use AIP and IP or ACP and CP to derive the conclusion! This is an assignment that …
  8. Philosophy

    I need help with this proof for my philosophy class. This proof is supposed to be done via indirect proof or conditional proof, so it is supposed to use AIP and IP or ACP and CP to derive the conclusion! This is an assignment that …
  9. geometry

    Construction: The midpoint of a line segment can be constructed. Theorem: If the consecutive midpoints of the sides of a parallelogram are joined in order, then the quadrilateral formed from the midpoints is a parallelogram. Write …
  10. informal Logic

    God must exist for there can be no other explanation for the order and complexity of the world. Some say there is no proof, but to me the proof is all around us. The conclusion of this argument is:

More Similar Questions