please suggest 3 reasons why Brutus' decision to assassinate Caesar was right or wrong.
http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/juliuscaesar/
After looking at this site, let us know what you think. We will be happy to make further suggestions if needed.
To evaluate the decision of Brutus to assassinate Caesar, it is essential to consider multiple perspectives. Here are three reasons commonly discussed for both the rightness and wrongness of Brutus' decision:
Reasons why Brutus' decision to assassinate Caesar was right:
1. Preservation of the Republic: One argument is that Brutus believed Caesar's growing power would eventually lead to the downfall of the Roman Republic, shifting Rome towards a monarchy. By removing Caesar, Brutus aimed to restore the balance of power and protect the Republican values that formed the foundation of Rome's governance.
How to get the answer: Research Brutus' motives and philosophical beliefs by exploring historical texts, including primary sources like the writings of Cicero and Plutarch, who provide valuable insights into the political context of the time.
2. Sense of Patriotism: Supporters of Brutus' decision argue that he made this difficult choice out of a deep loyalty to Rome. They believe he genuinely believed that killing Caesar was an act of love for his country and its people, driven by a desire to prevent corruption and tyranny from engulfing Rome.
How to get the answer: Analyze and evaluate Brutus' speeches from Shakespeare's play "Julius Caesar" and related historical accounts to fully understand his motivations and reasoning. Reading speeches like his famous soliloquy during Act II, Scene 1, or examining his public justifications, can provide valuable insights.
3. Commitment to the Roman People: Another proposed reason for the rightness of Brutus' decision is his belief that by eliminating Caesar, he was acting in the best interest of the Roman citizens. The assassination was seen as an attempt to liberate the people from a leader whose rule could potentially be oppressive and favoritistic.
How to get the answer: Study the historical background of the time and analyze the immediate reactions of the Roman citizens to Caesar's assassination. Delve into the socio-political climate of Rome to understand how the public viewed Caesar's rule and their response to his demise.
Reasons why Brutus' decision to assassinate Caesar was wrong:
1. Betrayal and Friendship: Critics argue that Caesar had trust and faith in Brutus, considering him a close friend and ally. They believe that Brutus' betrayal by participating in his assassination was an act of dishonor and treachery, tarnishing the noble virtues he claimed to embody.
How to get the answer: Study literature, such as Shakespeare's "Julius Caesar" and historical accounts that emphasize the friendship and camaraderie between Brutus and Caesar, like Plutarch's "Parallel Lives."
2. Legal and Constitutional Framework: Opponents suggest that Brutus' decision violated the existing laws and constitutional order of the Roman Republic. They argue that Caesar's authority was granted legally and that his assassination undermined the established norms and institutions of Rome.
How to get the answer: Examine Roman laws, constitutional documents, and political theories prevalent during the time of Caesar's rule. By studying the Roman legal system and analyzing contemporary writings on politics, you can better understand the context in which Brutus' action was evaluated.
3. Questionable Impact: Some critics claim that the assassination did not have the desired consequences and instead contributed to political instability and upheaval in Rome. They believe that it ultimately led to the rise of a different form of autocracy under figures like Octavian (later Emperor Augustus). This casts doubt on the effectiveness and long-term implications of Brutus' decision.
How to get the answer: Research and analyze the immediate aftermath of Caesar's assassination, including the political developments and consequences that ensued. Understanding the subsequent power struggles, such as the events of the Second Triumvirate, can help evaluate the impact of Brutus' actions on Roman political dynamics.
By exploring multiple viewpoints and considering the historical context, you can form a comprehensive understanding and draw your own conclusions regarding the rightness or wrongness of Brutus' decision to assassinate Caesar.