Calculus - Challenge question

posted by .

Our teacher gave us this problem as a challenge.
Some of us have been working on it for a few days

Prove that the largest area of any quadrilateral is obtained when opposite angles are supplementary.

Wow, what a classic and nice question, haven't seen it for years.
My compliments to your teacher for challenging you like that.

I am working at it, ....

Let the sides be a,b,c,and d. Let the angle between a and d be θ, let the angle between b and c be α.
Let x be the diagonal joining the other two angles.

By the Cosine Law: x^2 = a^2 + d^2 – 2ad cosθ and x^2 = b^2 + c^2 – 2bc cos α

Then a^2 + d^2 – 2ad cosθ = b^2 + c^2 – 2bc cos α

Differentiate with respect to θ

2ad sinθ = 2bc sinα (dα /dθ) -----> resulting in dα/dθ = (ad sinθ)/(bc sinα) (#1)

Let A be the area of the quadrilateral, then

A= ½ ad sin θ + ½ bc sin α now take dA/dθ

dA/dθ = ½ ad cos θ + ½ bc cosα(dα/dθ)
= 0 for a maximum of A

So ½ bc cosα(dα/dθ) = -½ ad cos θ

dα/dθ = -(ad cos θ)/(bc cosα) but from (#1) dα/dθ = (ad sinθ)/(bc sin α)

therefore: (ad sinθ)/(bc sin α) = - (ad cos θ)/(bc cosα)

or (sinθ)/(sin α) = - (cos θ)/(cosα)

sinθ cosα = - cos θ sin α
sinθ cosα + cos θ sin α = 0

sin(θ + α) = 0
so: θ + α = 0 , which is not possible, no quardateral or θ + α = 180º or θ + α = 360º also not possible
Therefore the opposite angles must be supplementary, i.e. they must add up to 180º

I can follow it up to the point where you said,

A= ½ ad sin ? + ½ bc sin ?

where does that come form?

Also yur secondlast line is confusing

For any triangle where you know two of the sides a and b and the angle between those 2 sides is A, then the area is ½ab sinA

for you second concern look at sin(θ + α) = 0
Where is the sine of an angle = 0?

at 0,180, 360....
but the angle was θ + α

1. θ + α could be 0, but that does not give us a quadrilateral
2. θ + α = 180º
3. θ + α = 360º this is also not possible, since the total of all 4 angles is 360

that leaves us with the inescapable conclusion that θ + α = 180º

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Geometry

    Suppose both pairs of opposite sides of a quadrilateral are parallel. Which angles of the quadrilateral must be supplementary?
  2. SCI/275

    CheckPoint #6: Water Resource Challenges Due Thursday *Post as an attachment** in your Individual Forum . Water Resource Challenges Review Ch. 10 and 11 of your text, then complete the following: Provide at least three freshwater and …
  3. HCS 320

    Can any one help me on this? I have no clue what to do. Any help is highly appreciated. Thanks give an example of intraorganizational communication challenge and what strategies you would use to overcome this challenge
  4. algebra homework

    I am having some problem with solving a problem that the teacher gave to us. I ahving been working on it, but I just can't seem to get it. I keep getting the answer 2(y-2)/y+2. 3/y-3/2y+4
  5. human relations

    learning is generally considered a lasting change in behavior based on a) practice and experience b) practice and challenge c) challenge and experience d.) challenge and reinforcement
  6. English

    Writeacher, I urgently need your help to check a few things. 1) Which of them is the girl to whom you are enganged?
  7. math

    Jayden wants to be a fast runner like his big brother, Isaac. Isaac encourages Jayden to do a “30 for 30” challenge. This would require Jayden to spend 30 minutes outside every day for 30 days doing some type of physical activity. …
  8. Challenge Help

    Ok so, my birthday is coming up and im planning my party. The theme is challenger, and I am finding all the most funest challenges. I am only 12 so nothing painful like the salt and ice challenge. I already have the bean boozled challenge, …
  9. Math

    My 10th grade teacher gave us geometry homework and this problem has me stumped for sure. This rhombus has three interior angles: (5x-2)°, (8y+2)°, and (3x+22)° . We are supposed to find the value of x and y. I tried to use an equation …
  10. Math

    Each of the following statements describes a quadrilateral. Which of the quadrilaterals are NOT parallelograms?

More Similar Questions