Psychology/Statistics
posted by Melissa .
I have a quick question for you all. I have done a repeated measures ANOVA for hypothetical data in my Stats class. There were 5 subjects.. all subjects rated their mood on a cloudy day, then they all rated their mood on a sunny day. In sum.. they all underwent the same order of reporting mood.
I found a significant effect of weather. Where I'm stuck is where my prof asked me "how sure can i be of my results?" I know drawbacks to repeated measures designs, but I'm not sure what to say beyond the usual "There could be spillover" problem. Thanks so much for any help you can offer!
My knee jerk reaction is to ask, "at what level of significance?" At the 10% level? at the 5% level? at the 1% level.
In other words, with respect to sampling "error" only, how sure are you of your results.
Your "spillover" comment suggest that your prof may be asking about nonsampling error; a very legitimate question, but hard to answer.
Thanks so much for responding. I think it was actually at the 2% level of significance.
The only thing my professor is askig is just generally "how sure can I be of my results", and he said just talk about drawbacks of the design... so I guess (hopefully) I'm on the right track.
Five subjects is a very small sample. How many measurements did you have on each subject? How did you control other factors that might effect mood (e.g., restrictions that might occur on cluody/stormy days)?
I'm not sure what you mean by "spillover," but do you know if the order of sunny and cloudy days had any effect?
Did you actually calculate the level of significance or is that just a personal estimate? ("I think it was....")
Possibly answering some of these questions will help you to estimate your sureness of your results and the conclusions they might indicate.
I hope this helps a little more. Thanks for asking.
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

stats
Eating raw fish (and enjoying it) is an acquired taste for many people who have never tried sushi. Ten people who had never before eaten sushi were asked to rate how much they liked it on a 100point scale (100=fantastic, 0=yuck) on … 
Psychology/Statistics
I have a quick question for you all. I have done a repeated measures ANOVA for hypothetical data in my Stats class. There were 5 subjects.. all subjects rated their mood on a cloudy day, then they all rated their mood on a sunny day. … 
PSYCHOLOGY STATISTICS
I have a question regarding my statistical analysis choice. I have 40 male and 40 female participants doing my experiment (involves looking at magazines, then filling in some questionnaire measures).  20 female participants will look … 
College psych  research class
Hi all. I have a question about creating graphs and other data tables using Excel spreadsheets et al. It's actually for a specific kind of project where I'm trying to work on taking a theoretical sample of subjects and and I'm torn … 
Statistic
The television network you addressed in Week 4 is asking you to compare the moods of groups that watch different types of shows. You can choose what they mean by moods. You may compare them on general mood, happiness, depression, frustration, … 
statistics
A researcher reports an Fratio with df = 2, 36 from an independentmeasures research study. Based on the df values, how many treatments were compared in the study and what was the total number of subjects participating in the study? 
psychology statistics
why can we use the same multiple comparison procedures for between subjects, repeated measures, and mixed designs without changing the formulas 
statistics
In a class of 100 ,84% of the students have taken politics &16% of student have taken history.how many students have taken both subject of all the students take at least one of these subjects? 
Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences
Complete an independent project, collect data from your observation experiment and perform a oneway, betweensubjects ANOVA on the data using the definitional formula.Include the following: 1. description of research project that … 
Statistics
Can 2 X 2 betweensubject ANOVA be used if participants were from the same class and all completed the same survey?