posted by .

Hi, ummm, can someone please help me with this question?

What are some reasons that the victory of the management in the Homestead Strike was positive for American society? And negative?

Thank you!

I'm not much of a history person, but I think this might help a bit:

"The strike's conclusion

Support for the strikers evaporated. The AFL refused to call for a boycott of Carnegie products in September 1892. Wholesale crossing of the picket line occurred, first among Eastern European immigrants and then among all workers. The strike had collapsed so much that the state militia pulled out on October 13, ending the 95-day occupation. The AA was nearly bankrupted by the job action. Nearly 1,600 men were receiving a total of $10,000 a week in relief from union coffers. It was time to end the Homestead strike. With only 192 out of more than 3,800 strikers in attendance, the Homestead chapter of the AA voted, 101 to 91, to return to work on November 20, 1892.[43]

In the end, only four workers were ever tried on the actual charges filed on July 18. Three AA members were found innocent of all charges. Hugh Dempsey, the leader of the local Knights of Labor District Assembly, was found guilty of conspiring to poison nonunion workers at the plant—despite the state's star witness recanting his testimony on the stand. Dempsey served a seven-year prison term. In February 1893, Knox and the union agreed to drop the charges filed against one another, and no further prosecutions emerged from the events at Homestead.[44]

The striking AA affiliate in Beaver Falls gave in the same day as the Homestead lodge. The AA affiliate at Union Mills held out until August 14, 1893. But by then the union had only 53 members and the union had been broke, for the company had been operating the plant at full capacity since September 1892.[45]


The Homestead strike broke the AA as a force in the American labor movement. Many employers refused to sign contracts with their AA unions while the strike lasted. A deepening in 1889 of the Long Depression led most steel companies to seek wage decreases similar to those imposed at Homestead.[46]

An organizing drive at the Homestead plant in 1896 was crushed by Frick. In May 1899, 300 Homestead workers actually formed an AA lodge, but Frick ordered the Homestead works shut down and the unionization effort collapsed. Carnegie Steel remained nonunion for the next 40 years.[47]

De-unionization efforts throughout the Midwest began against the AA in 1897 when Jones and Laughlin Steel refused to sign a contract. By 1900, not a single steel plant in Pennsylvania remained union. The AA presence in Ohio and Illinois continued for a few more years, but the union continued to collapse. Many lodges disbanded, their members disillusioned. Others were easily broken in short battles. Carnegie Steel's Mingo Junction, Ohio plant was the last major unionized steel mill in the country. But it, too, successfully withdrew recognition without a fight in 1903.[48]

AA membership sagged to 10,000 in 1894 from its high of over 24,000 in 1891. A year later, it was down to 8,000. A 1901 strike against U.S. Steel collapsed. By 1909, membership in the AA had sunk to 6,300. A nationwide steel strike in 1919 also was unsuccessful. [49]

The AA maintained a rump membership in the steel industry until its takeover by the Steel Workers Organizing Committee in 1936. The two organizations officially disbanded and formed the United Steelworkers May 22, 1942."

I got that off of Wikipedia.
Good luck!

Thanks, but I already read that.

Thanks that was a good message to me. Something I really never never knew.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. us history

    How did the Homestead Strike influence the fact that President Grover Cleveland won the 1888 election?
  2. Fat People in American Society

    Can someone help me research this question: What are some positive contributions that fat people have made to society?
  3. US History

    1) Which man does not belong in the same group with the others?
  4. History

    My question is this: What were some positive and negative effects that John D. Rockefeller had on big business in the late 19th century?
  5. APUSH

    In the Spanish-American War... a.) America's victory could be attributed in large part to expert preparation b.) More American soldiers died from disease than battle c.) The American victory in the decisive battle at Santiago depended …
  6. History

    Could someone please help with these questions?
  7. algebra

    Could someone please help me with this? (1) If x is a nonzero real number, is x–2 always positive, always negative, or positive or negative depending on whether x is positive or negative?
  8. Statistics

    The rate of chlamydia infection was reported as 2.78% in a recent year. Under certain conditions, a preliminary screening test for the chlamydia bacterium is correct 96% of the time. One person is randomly selected from the population. …
  9. Math

    We are adding positive and negative numbers. The question is State positive or negative or it depends along with my answers. Are these correct?
  10. Names in American Society

    In American society, most people take on the last name of their father at their birth. This kind of system is known as what?

More Similar Questions