Post a New Question

critical thinking

posted by .

is this an example of an invalid argument

All crows are black
John is black
Therefor, John is a crow.

is this an example of a unsound argument

All dogs are black
Lassie is a dog
Lassie is a cat

Please tell me if this is right.


You're right for both arguments.

The premise for the first statement is correct. But obviously the conclusion is wrong -- making the argument invalid.

The premise for the second argument is not correct. Therefore it is both invalid and unsound.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. critical thinking

    I was just wondering if you could give me some tips to help eliminate invalid and unsound claims in writing. Honestly, sometimes we are so blinded by our own thinking, it is difficult. In my experience, peer review is probably the …
  2. CRT - agument follow up

    Thank you for all your help tonight Ms. Sue - I have a few more questions before I'm done! From the argument I cited - would this be a good explanation of valid/invalid, strong or weak, sound or unsound The author’s argument is invalid, …
  3. critical thinking

    Premise- Since most all disease can be effectively prevented by a healthy lifestyle. Conclusion-Animal activist sometimes contend that medical research is unneccessary. Is this a valid/sound argument or is this an ivalid/unsound argument?
  4. Critical Thinking 205

    which one of these make an argument the best?
  5. English

    1. I have two dogs. One is black, and the other is black and white. 2. I have two dogs. One is black, and the second is black and white. (Which expression is correct?
  6. PHI 103

    "All dogs hate cats. Sirius is a dog. So Sirius hates cats" is an example of a (Points : 1) sound inductive argument. valid deductive argument. invalid inductive argument. weak deductive argument. I am confused a little about this …
  7. Math for Liberal Arts

    Directions: Define the necessary symbols, rewrite the argument in symbolic form, and us a truth table to determine whether the argument is valid. If the argument is invalid, interpret the specific circumstances that cause the argument …
  8. biology urgent

    In mice, a gene controlling coat colour has 2 alleles; B (black) and b (white). A pure breeding black mouse is crossed to a white mouse and all the offspring are black. The offspring are then crossed to white mice. The phenotypes of …
  9. Logical Fallacy

    Penguins are black and white. Some old TV shows are black white. Therefore, some penguins are old TV shows. Is this a valid and unsound argument?
  10. math

    I am having trouble understanding how to solve this problem. I found an answer, about 74.2%, but I am not sure if that is correct. Any help would be greatly appreciated! A chess board has 64 squares, 32 white and 32 black, and is played …

More Similar Questions

Post a New Question