Data from a data table
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER
The term "data from a data table" is not usable in CER as it is redundant. "Data" already implies information obtained from a data table or any other source. Therefore, including "data from a data table" would be repetitive and unnecessary.
Stating an answer to a specific question
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER
While stating an answer to a specific question can be a part of a CER (claim, evidence, reasoning) framework, it is important to note that simply stating an answer without supporting evidence and reasoning may not be sufficient. In a CER, the claim is the answer to the question, the evidence supports the claim by providing data or observations, and the reasoning explains the logical connection between the evidence and the claim. Therefore, just stating an answer without providing evidence and reasoning would not be considered a complete CER.
Observations from an experiment in class
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER
Observations from an experiment in class can be used in a CER (claim, evidence, reasoning) framework. In this case, the observations would serve as the evidence to support the claim. The claim would be a statement or conclusion based on the observations made during the experiment. The reasoning would then explain the logical connection between the evidence and the claim, providing the explanation or interpretation of the data. Therefore, observations from an experiment in class can be used effectively in a CER.
Facts from a scientific article
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER
Facts from a scientific article can certainly be used in a CER (claim, evidence, reasoning) framework. In this case, the facts from the scientific article would serve as the evidence to support the claim. The claim would be a statement or conclusion based on the facts presented in the article. The reasoning would then explain the logical connection between the evidence (facts) and the claim, providing explanation, interpretation, or analysis. Therefore, facts from a scientific article can be effectively utilized in a CER.
My personal opinion
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER
Your personal opinion can be used in a CER (claim, evidence, reasoning) framework, but it is important to differentiate between personal opinion and objective evidence. While your opinion can function as the claim or conclusion, it is necessary to support it with evidence - either empirical data, research, or credible sources. The evidence provides the foundation for your claim, and the reasoning then explains the logical connection between the evidence and the claim, providing a logical argument or explanation. However, it is crucial to avoid relying solely on personal opinion as evidence, as it may lack objectivity and relevance. Including well-supported evidence is necessary to have a strong and valid CER.
Should only be one sentence long
claim
evidence
reasoning
not usable in CER