In a lab investigation, students had to identify different mineral specimens. Which property is the LEAST reliable for identifying one mineral from another?
streak
hardness
cleavage
mineral color
Copied from Google.
color test
The color test is the least reliable test because many different minerals have similar colors. A similar test to color is the streak test. The streak test matches the color of the mineral's powder. Interestingly, the mineral color and the streak color are often different.
The least reliable property for identifying one mineral from another is mineral color. Mineral color can be influenced by impurities and variations, making it less consistent and more subjective compared to other properties such as streak, hardness, and cleavage, which are more distinctive and standardized characteristics used in mineral identification.
To determine which property is the least reliable for identifying one mineral from another, you can compare the properties of the options provided - streak, hardness, cleavage, and mineral color - and assess their reliability in distinguishing minerals.
Streak: The streak refers to the color of a mineral's powder when it is scraped across an unglazed porcelain plate. While streak can be useful in identification, it is not always reliable as some minerals may have different streak colors than their actual mineral color.
Hardness: The hardness of a mineral is determined by its resistance to scratching and is measured using the Mohs scale. Hardness is generally a reliable property for mineral identification because most minerals have a specific range of hardness. However, it is possible for different minerals to have similar hardness values, making it less reliable in some cases.
Cleavage: Cleavage refers to the tendency of a mineral to break along certain planes and produce smooth flat surfaces. It is generally a reliable property for identifying minerals as it is unique to each mineral. However, some minerals may exhibit similar types of cleavage, reducing its reliability in those cases.
Mineral color: While mineral color can be visually striking and commonly observed, it is generally considered the least reliable property for identifying minerals. This is because many different minerals can have the same or very similar colors, making it difficult to differentiate them based on color alone. Additionally, the same mineral can come in various colors, depending on impurities present in the crystal structure.
Overall, considering the properties mentioned, mineral color is typically the least reliable property for distinguishing one mineral from another. Thus, students should rely more on streak, hardness, and cleavage for accurate mineral identification.