Read Amy’s Metaphor and From Scratch from Unit 9 Lesson 5. You will then write a 5 paragraph essay comparing and contrasting the two stories. Use details from both stories in your essay. You are required to quote or paraphrase information from the stories in your essay. You must include your Check My Work link with your essay. Your essay must be in MLA citation. This means you will have in-text citations and a Works Cited page. The lesson may prompt you to write 3 paragraphs. The state of Arizona requires 5 paragraphs for 6th grade. You are required to write 5 paragraphs for this assignment.
In Amy's Metaphor, the narrator reflects on the struggles she faced as a child growing up in a dysfunctional family. She uses the metaphor of a broken mirror to illustrate how she felt fragmented and incomplete as a result of her upbringing. The narrator describes how she tried to piece herself back together, but ultimately realized that she was not responsible for the brokenness she felt. This story highlights the impact that family dynamics can have on a person's sense of self-worth and identity.
On the other hand, From Scratch tells the story of a young girl who discovers her passion for baking and uses it as a way to connect with others and find a sense of belonging. The narrator describes how she learned to bake from scratch, starting with simple recipes and gradually experimenting with more complex creations. Baking becomes a form of therapy for the narrator, allowing her to express her creativity and find comfort in times of stress. This story emphasizes the power of pursuing one's passions and finding joy in the simple pleasures of life.
While Amy's Metaphor and From Scratch are both stories about personal growth and self-discovery, they approach these themes in different ways. In Amy's Metaphor, the narrator's journey towards self-acceptance is a painful and introspective process, as she grapples with the emotional scars of her past. The broken mirror serves as a powerful symbol of the narrator's fragmented sense of self, highlighting the struggle to reconcile her past with her present.
In contrast, From Scratch focuses on the transformative power of creativity and passion in overcoming adversity. The narrator's love for baking becomes a source of strength and resilience, allowing her to find joy and fulfillment in the midst of hardship. Baking serves as a metaphor for the narrator's ability to create beauty and meaning out of challenging circumstances, highlighting the importance of pursuing one's passions as a means of self-expression and healing.
Overall, both stories illustrate the importance of self-reflection and self-expression in navigating the complexities of life. While Amy's Metaphor delves into the darker aspects of personal growth, From Scratch offers a more uplifting and hopeful perspective on finding purpose and fulfillment through creativity and passion. These stories remind us that while we may be shaped by our past experiences, we also have the power to redefine ourselves and create our own paths towards healing and self-discovery.
Works Cited
Author's last name, First Name. "Title of Story." Title of Unit, Publisher, Date, URL.
Check My Work: [insert URL]