In a well-written, thoughtful response of at least one page, reflect on one of the stories "The Jilting of Granny Weatherall" or "Chrysanthemums." YOur response might make a personal connection to one of the stories, might make connections between the two stories, or may just be a relection on something that stood out to you about one fo the stories--something that you liked or didn't like, perhaps. Although this is a personal reflection, and you can use "I" in the piece.
😐 9 years later..
They are saying that you can use the word "I" in writing this response to one of those stories. Your teacher wants you to say how you related to that story. After you have written, please repost and a teacher will be happy to make suggestions/corrections.
To analyze and reflect upon a story like "The Jilting of Granny Weatherall" or "Chrysanthemums," you need to start by understanding the themes, characters, and events within the story. Both stories explore deep and complex emotions, and by delving into them, you can gain a richer understanding and appreciation of the narratives.
To begin, read the story of your choice carefully, paying attention to the details, imagery, and symbolism employed by the author. Understanding the writer's perspective and intentions is crucial in providing a thoughtful response.
"The Jilting of Granny Weatherall" by Katherine Anne Porter tells the story of an elderly woman on her deathbed reflecting on her life. Granny Weatherall is consumed by the memory of being jilted at the altar by her fiancé, George. Throughout the story, Granny attempts to come to terms with her past and confront her own mortality.
On the other hand, "Chrysanthemums" by John Steinbeck explores the repression and unfulfilled desires of Elisa Allen, a woman trapped in a stifling marriage. Steinbeck uses vivid imagery and symbolism, particularly with the chrysanthemums, to convey the inner world of the protagonist as she longs for freedom and self-expression.
When reflecting on your chosen story, it can be helpful to examine the characters' motivations, conflicts, and the way the narrative is structured. How do these aspects contribute to the overall themes or messages conveyed by the author?
In your personal response, you can focus on various aspects that resonated with you. For example, you might discuss how Granny Weatherall's resilience and her ability to maintain a facade of strength despite her vulnerable state impacted you. Or, you could highlight the significance of the chrysanthemums in Elisa's story and how they symbolize her repressed desires.
Additionally, you can draw connections or comparisons between the stories. Both portray strong female characters who face emotional turmoil and seek personal fulfillment. By exploring the similarities and differences in their journeys, you can delve into broader themes of gender roles, societal expectations, or the human condition.
As you craft your response, consider incorporating textual evidence to support your insights. By selecting specific quotes or scenes that left a lasting impression on you, you can provide a more meaningful analysis of the stories.
It's crucial to remember that personal reflection is subjective. What matters most is to ground your thoughts in the story and your own interpretation, drawing upon elements that resonated with you personally.
Remember, reflective writing is an opportunity to demonstrate your understanding of the text and your ability to analyze and articulate your thoughts effectively.