B. Debating the Limits of Online Speech. Schools have to protect students’ right to free speech, but they
also have to protect students from harm. So what do you think: Is it appropriate for schools to punish
students for certain kinds of online speech? For the scenarios below, place a Y for yes and an N for no.
Choose any answer and explain your reasons for it.
A.___when sexist or racist comments are posted
about other students
B. ____ when students criticize the administration
and its decisions
C. ____ when students demean or make fun of a
teacher
D. ____ when students post photos or
videos of other students that are revealing
E. ____ when students spread hurtful lies and
rumors about other students
F. ____ when students spread hurtful lies and
rumors about teachers
G. ____ when students post altered photos to create
rude images of students or teachers
H. ____ when students cyberbully other
students
Give the reasons for one of your answers.
A. Y (Yes, it is appropriate for schools to punish students for posting sexist or racist comments about other students)
Students should not be allowed to engage in behavior that is harmful, discriminatory, and creates a hostile environment for their peers. Sexist and racist comments have the potential to cause emotional harm and perpetuate harmful stereotypes. Punishing students for this type of online speech sends a clear message that this behavior is not acceptable and helps protect the well-being of all students in the school community.