Your essay must be at least 3 paragraphs.
Read the stories & choose a life lesson OR important value that you feel the readers should learn based on the younger brothers in BOTH stories. Find evidence in BOTH stories to support your thesis.
Answer the question, “How are the younger boys DIFFERENT from the older brothers in BOTH stories?” and find evidence from BOTH stories to support your answer.
Find TWO examples of how the authors’ use of plot events, language, and literary devices give BOTH stories meaning & show what the authors want the readers to learn (Author’s Message). Here is a link to a list of Literary Devices to help you determine what was used in the stories.
Your analysis must be submitted in MLA format & include a Works Cited Page for the 2 stories.
You must submit your analysis to the Paper Review Center & provide their feedback along with your updated analysis (showing that you utilized their feedback) in the dropbox. Click here to watch a video on how to submit to the Paper Review Center. Click here to read how to download their feedback.
You will be graded using the rubric on the next page (also linked here)
In the stories "The Scarlet Ibis" by James Hurst and "The Brothers" by Bjornstjerne Bjornson, the younger brothers play significant roles and provide valuable life lessons for the readers. In both stories, the younger brothers exhibit qualities such as determination, resilience, and loyalty that the readers can learn from. In "The Scarlet Ibis," the younger brother, Doodle, shows incredible determination and perseverance in trying to please his older brother, despite his physical limitations. This teaches readers the importance of never giving up and always striving to do their best, no matter the obstacles they may face.
On the other hand, in "The Brothers," the younger brother demonstrates loyalty and sacrifice towards his older brother, even when faced with difficult decisions. This highlights the importance of family bonds and unconditional love, showing readers the value of standing by their loved ones in times of need. The contrast between the younger and older brothers in both stories emphasizes the different perspectives and values that each sibling holds, allowing readers to reflect on their own relationships with their family members.
The authors of both stories use plot events, language, and literary devices to convey important messages to the readers. For example, in "The Scarlet Ibis," the use of symbolism, such as the scarlet ibis bird, represents both the beauty and fragility of life. This conveys the message of appreciating the uniqueness of each individual and cherishing the time spent with loved ones. Similarly, in "The Brothers," the plot events surrounding the younger brother's decision to sacrifice his own happiness for the well-being of his older brother showcase the theme of selflessness and compassion.
Overall, both stories offer valuable life lessons and insights into the dynamics of sibling relationships. By analyzing the younger brothers in both stories and exploring the authors' use of literary devices, readers can gain a deeper understanding of the messages conveyed and apply them to their own lives. Through the characters' experiences, readers are encouraged to reflect on the importance of determination, loyalty, and compassion in their relationships with others.
Works Cited:
Hurst, James. "The Scarlet Ibis."
Bjornson, Bjornstjerne. "The Brothers."